Best All Season Tire on Snow and Ice: 5 Picks

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you.

Snow is forgiving. Ice is not. A tyre that grips packed snow can still slide on a glazed junction, and the difference between stopping in time and sliding on is the tread pattern and the rubber compound, not the badge on the sidewall.

All five tyres in this guide are Michelin all-season tyres, the range with the clearest published snow and ice test evidence. Two carry the three-peak mountain snowflake mark for severe snow, the others trade snow grip for tread life, quiet miles or sports handling, and they are not the same tyre in different sizes.

This guide compares all five by snow grip, ice braking, tread life, noise and fitment, using independent test summaries and Michelin published figures, so you can buy the tyre that matches your winter, not the one with the loudest advert.

The 30-second answer

Buy the MICHELIN CrossClimate2 All-Season Tire 235/55R18 100V Check Price for the strongest snow grip of any all-season tyre here. Buy the MICHELIN Defender2 All-Season Tire 225/60R17 99H Check Price for the longest tread life and the quietest dry-road drive. Buy the MICHELIN Primacy Tour A/S All-Season Car Tire 225/45R19/XL 96W Check Price for the quietest touring ride. Buy the MICHELIN Pilot Sport All Season 4 Performance Tire 245/45ZR19/XL 102Y Check Price for snow grip with sports-car handling. Buy the MICHELIN CrossClimate2 All-Season Car Tire SUV CUV 245/45R17/XL 99V Check Price for the same snow grip on an SUV or crossover.

How we researched this guide

We profiled five Michelin all-season tyres, checked Amazon listing data for each size through the Creators API, and reviewed Michelin published figures, Tire Rack test summaries and owner reports in retailer reviews about snow braking, ice braking, tread life, noise and fitment. Where a listing does not publish a figure, we say so instead of guessing.

Our quick picks

Best Overall for Snow

MICHELIN CrossClimate2 All-Season Tire 235/55R18 100V

Best for the strongest snow grip of any all-season tyre here: a three-peak mountain snowflake mark, a V-shaped tread that bites snow, and test results that show far shorter snow braking than the Defender 2.

Best for Long Tread Life

MICHELIN Defender2 All-Season Tire 225/60R17 99H

Best for the longest tread life: an 80,000-mile warranty, a 840 UTQG rating, and a Consumer Reports best all-season result for drivers who value miles over snow.

Best Quiet Touring

MICHELIN Primacy Tour A/S All-Season Car Tire 225/45R19/XL 96W

Best for the quietest touring ride: PIANO noise tuning, a 55,000-mile warranty and a comfort-first design for premium sedans and crossovers.

Best Performance in Snow

MICHELIN Pilot Sport All Season 4 Performance Tire 245/45ZR19/XL 102Y

Best for snow grip with sports-car handling: a 540AAA UTQG rating, 10 percent more snow traction than the tyre it replaced, and the first all-season tyre chosen for a Corvette.

Best for SUVs and Crossovers

MICHELIN CrossClimate2 All-Season Car Tire SUV CUV 245/45R17/XL 99V

Best for the same snow grip on an SUV or crossover: the CrossClimate2 in SUV and crossover sizes, with the same three-peak mark and the same 60,000-mile warranty.

Quick comparison

ProductSnow mark and warrantyUseWarrantyCheck Price
MICHELIN CrossClimate2 All-Season Tire 235/55R18 100V3PMSF, 60,000-mile warrantyRegular snow and ice60,000-mile treadwear warrantyCheck Price
MICHELIN Defender2 All-Season Tire 225/60R17 99HM+S only, 80,000-mile warrantyBig miles, mild winters80,000-mile treadwear warrantyCheck Price
MICHELIN Primacy Tour A/S All-Season Car Tire 225/45R19/XL 96WM+S only, 55,000-mile warrantyQuiet touring, light snow55,000-mile treadwear warranty per retailer listingsCheck Price
MICHELIN Pilot Sport All Season 4 Performance Tire 245/45ZR19/XL 102Y540AAA, 45,000-mile warrantySporty cars, snow and dry grip45,000-mile treadwear warrantyCheck Price
MICHELIN CrossClimate2 All-Season Car Tire SUV CUV 245/45R17/XL 99V3PMSF, 60,000-mile warrantySUVs and crossovers in snow60,000-mile treadwear warrantyCheck Price

How to choose an all-season tyre for snow and ice

Snow mark first

The three-peak mountain snowflake mark means the tyre passed a regulated snow-traction test, while the M+S mark means only that the tread pattern looks like it should work in mud and snow. For regular snow and ice, buy the three-peak mark. For a dusting once a year, the M+S mark is enough. Best All-Season Tires Under 200

Your real winter

Count the snow days, not the cold days. If you drive on snow and ice every week, buy the tyre with the strongest snow braking. If your winters are cold and dry with snow twice a year, a touring tyre with a long life serves you better and costs less per mile. Best Garage Security Cameras Under 100

Tread life against snow and ice

A long-life touring tyre trades snow grip for miles, and a snow-focused tyre trades miles for grip. The Defender 2 warranty is 80,000 miles and the CrossClimate 2 is 60,000 miles, so the choice is about 20,000 miles against far shorter snow braking. Pick the side that matches your winter. Best Garage Storage

Noise and comfort

A quiet touring tyre with noise tuning makes a long motorway commute far easier on the ears, while a performance tyre is firmer and louder. If you drive big motorway miles, buy the quietest tyre that still handles your snow. If you enjoy a fast road, the performance tyre is worth the noise. Best Hard Tonneau Cover Under 500

Your car and size

Check the size on your door placard before you order, because a tyre that fits a sedan will not fit an SUV and the listing you buy covers one size only. Match the size, the load rating and the speed rating exactly, and use the size selector on the listing to find your size. Best Performance Monitors Under 100

One tyre or two sets

An all-weather tyre with the three-peak mark covers the whole year for most drivers, with no seasonal swap to book. A dedicated winter tyre still wins in deep snow, on ice and in mountain passes, but it means a second set of tyres and a swap twice a year. For most drivers, one good all-weather tyre is the simpler answer. Best Storage Bins

All-season tyres for snow and ice by budget

TierWhat you getExample pick
Best value for snowA three-peak marked all-weather tyre with a 60,000-mile warranty.CrossClimate2 235/55R18
Best value for milesA long-life touring tyre with an 80,000-mile warranty for mild winters.Defender2 225/60R17
Best value for comfortA quiet touring tyre with noise tuning for premium cars.Primacy Tour A/S 225/45R19

Types of all-season tyre for snow and ice

TypeHow it worksBest forWatch out for
All-weather, three-peak markV-shaped tread and a compound that stays flexible in the cold.Regular snow and iceShorter tread life than a touring tyre
Touring all-season, M+SLong-life compound built for miles and quiet motorways.Big miles in mild wintersNo severe-snow certification
Grand-touring all-seasonNoise-tuned tread for premium cars and quiet motorways.Quiet touring, light snowLight snow only
Ultra-high-performance all-seasonSports handling with snow grip built in.Sporty cars in snowShortest warranty, firmer ride

Detailed reviews

Five Michelin all-season tyres, each reviewed on snow grip, ice braking, tread life, noise and fitment, with test summaries and published figures. All five picks are Michelin, so the comparison is between Michelin models, not between brands.

Best Overall for Snow: MICHELIN CrossClimate2 All-Season Tire 235/55R18 100V

Best Overall for Snow

Why the CrossClimate2 235/55R18 is our pick

The CrossClimate2 is the snow pick because it is built as an all-weather tyre rather than a traditional all-season. It carries the three-peak mountain snowflake mark, which means it passed a regulated snow-traction test, and its V-shaped tread and thermally adaptive compound stay flexible in the cold. The listing names a 235/55R18 100V size, a 60,000-mile treadwear warranty and a 640BA UTQG rating.

CrossClimate2 235/55R18 key specs

  • Type: All-weather all-season tyre
  • Brand: Michelin
  • Model: CrossClimate2
  • Size: 235/55R18 100V
  • Snow mark: Three-peak mountain snowflake
  • Treadwear warranty: 60,000 miles
  • UTQG: 640BA
  • Compound: Thermally adaptive all-weather
  • Tread: Directional V-ramp pattern
  • Noise tuning: PIANO Noise Reduction Tuning
  • Load capacity: 1,764 pounds (load index 100)
  • Speed rating: V

CrossClimate2 235/55R18: fits and best for

The CrossClimate2 fits a crossover or SUV that takes a 235/55R18 tyre, drives through real winter weather and needs one tyre for the whole year. If your winters are mild and you drive big motorway miles, the Defender 2 below lasts longer, and if your car takes a different size, the CrossClimate2 in your size is the same tyre in your fitment.

CrossClimate2 235/55R18 pros and watch-outs

  • Three-peak snowflake certified for severe snow
  • Far shorter snow braking than the Defender 2
  • Stays flexible in cold weather
  • Strong wet and dry braking too
  • One tyre for the whole year, no seasonal swap
  • Shorter treadwear warranty than the Defender 2
  • Directional tread needs correct fitting rotation
  • Not a dedicated winter tyre for deep snow
  • Softer ride feel than a touring tyre

CrossClimate2 235/55R18: what owners report

Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the CrossClimate2 feels secure from the first snowfall, with confident braking and steady handling on packed snow and slush. . Tire Reviews Defender 2 versus CrossClimate 2

Other owners note the tyre wears faster than a long-life touring tyre on big motorway miles, and the directional tread needs care at fitting. . Tire Advise Defender 2 versus CrossClimate 2

CrossClimate2 235/55R18: who should not buy

Do not buy the CrossClimate2 if you drive almost no snow and big motorway miles, because the Defender 2 lasts longer for that job. Do not buy it as a substitute for a dedicated winter tyre if you drive through deep snow, ice and mountain passes all winter.

CrossClimate2 235/55R18: pair it with

Pair it with a tyre pressure check every month in winter, because cold air drops pressures and a soft tyre loses snow grip fast.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Check the rotation arrows on the sidewall at fitting, because the directional tread only works when every tyre points the right way. Best Tool Storage

Best for Long Tread Life: MICHELIN Defender2 All-Season Tire 225/60R17 99H

Best for Long Tread Life

Why the Defender2 225/60R17 is our pick

The Defender2 is the long-life pick because it is built around tread life first. Michelin lists an 80,000-mile treadwear warranty on most sizes, the UTQG treadwear rating is 840, and Consumer Reports named it the best all-season tyre in its 2026 test with an estimated tread life around 100,000 miles. The listing names a 225/60R17 99H size and a 1,709 pound load capacity. The trade-off is honest: it carries the M+S mud and snow mark but not the three-peak mountain snowflake, so it handles a dusting of snow and cold dry roads, but it is not the tyre for regular snow.

Defender2 225/60R17 key specs

  • Type: All-season touring tyre
  • Brand: Michelin
  • Model: Defender2
  • Size: 225/60R17 99H
  • Snow mark: M+S only, no three-peak mark
  • Treadwear warranty: 80,000 miles
  • UTQG: 840
  • Compound: Long-life touring compound
  • Load capacity: 1,709 pounds (load index 99)
  • Speed rating: H
  • Test result: Best all-season, Consumer Reports 2026
  • Estimated tread life: Around 100,000 miles per Consumer Reports

Defender2 225/60R17: fits and best for

The Defender2 fits a driver who covers big annual miles in a mild climate and wants a tyre that lasts years, not seasons. It suits mild-weather states and cars that see snow only once or twice a year. If you drive regular snow and ice, buy the CrossClimate2 instead, because the Defender 2 stops far longer on snow.

Defender2 225/60R17 pros and watch-outs

  • Longest treadwear warranty here at 80,000 miles
  • Best all-season in the Consumer Reports 2026 test
  • Quiet and comfortable on motorways
  • Strong dry and wet braking
  • Longest-lasting tyre in this guide
  • No three-peak snowflake certification
  • Stops far longer on snow than the CrossClimate 2
  • Sudden breakaway in snow per testers
  • Calm rather than sharp steering feel

Defender2 225/60R17: what owners report

Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the Defender2 rides quietly and comfortably for years, with tread life that outlasts the tyres it replaced. . Road Hubs Defender2 review

Other owners note the tyre struggles in real snow and needs care on icy side streets, and a few say the steering feels calm rather than sharp. . Top Tire Review CrossClimate 2 versus Defender 2

Defender2 225/60R17: who should not buy

Do not buy the Defender2 if you drive regular snow and ice, because it has no severe-snow certification and stops far longer on snow than the CrossClimate 2. Do not buy it if you want sharp sports-car handling, because it is a calm touring tyre.

Defender2 225/60R17: pair it with

Pair it with a regular rotation every 6,000 to 8,000 miles, because even wear is what turns the long warranty into long real life.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Check the tread depth before the first winter, because a worn touring tyre loses what snow grip it had faster than a new one. Best Tow Ropes Under 100

Best Quiet Touring: MICHELIN Primacy Tour A/S All-Season Car Tire 225/45R19/XL 96W

Best Quiet Touring

Why the Primacy Tour A/S 225/45R19 is our pick

The Primacy Tour A/S is the quiet pick because Michelin built it for premium and luxury cars where comfort matters as much as grip. The listing names a 225/45R19/XL 96W size, a 540AA UTQG rating, an advanced performance compound that stays flexible at low temperatures, and sharp lateral grooves that bite into loose snow. The treadwear warranty is 55,000 miles per retailer listings, and the tyre carries the M+S mark but not the three-peak snowflake.

Primacy Tour A/S 225/45R19 key specs

  • Type: Grand-touring all-season tyre
  • Brand: Michelin
  • Model: Primacy Tour A/S
  • Size: 225/45R19/XL 96W
  • Snow mark: M+S only, no three-peak mark
  • Treadwear warranty: 55,000 miles per retailer listings
  • UTQG: 540AA
  • Compound: Advanced performance compound
  • Noise tuning: PIANO Noise Reduction Tuning
  • Load capacity: 1,565 pounds (load index 96)
  • Speed rating: W
  • Fitment: Premium sedans, crossovers and SUVs

Primacy Tour A/S 225/45R19: fits and best for

The Primacy Tour A/S fits a premium sedan or crossover driver who wants the quietest, smoothest ride in this guide and drives through light snow at most. If you drive regular snow, the CrossClimate2 is the safer tyre, and if you want sports handling, the Pilot Sport All Season 4 below is the pick.

Primacy Tour A/S 225/45R19 pros and watch-outs

  • Quietest tread design among leading competitors
  • Smooth and comfortable on motorways
  • Compound stays flexible in cold weather
  • Sharp grooves bite loose snow
  • First choice of many premium car makers
  • No three-peak snowflake certification
  • Shorter warranty than the Defender 2
  • Light snow only, not regular winter driving
  • Premium sizes cost more per tyre

Primacy Tour A/S 225/45R19: what owners report

Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the Primacy Tour A/S is noticeably quieter than the tyres it replaced, with a smooth ride that suits long motorway runs. . Discounted Wheel Warehouse tyre comparison

Other owners note the tyre is not a snow tyre and needs care on icy roads, and a few say the tread wears faster than a long-life touring tyre on heavy cars. . Finance First CrossClimate 2 versus Defender 2

Primacy Tour A/S 225/45R19: who should not buy

Do not buy the Primacy Tour A/S if you drive regular snow and ice, because it has no severe-snow certification. Do not buy it if you want the longest tread life, because the Defender 2 warranty is far longer.

Primacy Tour A/S 225/45R19: pair it with

Pair it with a monthly pressure check, because a quiet touring tyre loses its best ride quality first when pressures drift low.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Rotate the tyres with every oil change, because even wear keeps the quiet tread quiet for the full life of the tyre. Battery Tender Junior vs NOCO Genius1

Best Performance in Snow: MICHELIN Pilot Sport All Season 4 Performance Tire 245/45ZR19/XL 102Y

Best Performance in Snow

Why the Pilot Sport All Season 4 is our pick

The Pilot Sport All Season 4 is the performance pick because it brings sports-car handling to a tyre that still works in snow. The listing names a 245/45ZR19/XL 102Y size, a 540AAA UTQG rating and a 45,000-mile treadwear warranty. It is the first all-season tyre chosen by Chevrolet for the Corvette, and it finished first in snow braking in the 2024 Tire Rack ultra-high-performance all-season test.

Pilot Sport All Season 4 key specs

  • Type: Ultra-high-performance all-season tyre
  • Brand: Michelin
  • Model: Pilot Sport All Season 4
  • Size: 245/45ZR19/XL 102Y
  • Snow mark: M+S, no three-peak mark published
  • Treadwear warranty: 45,000 miles
  • UTQG: 540AAA
  • Snow traction: 10 percent more than A/S 3+ per Michelin
  • Dry braking: 4 percent better than A/S 3+ per Michelin
  • Wet braking: 5 percent better than A/S 3+ per Michelin
  • Load capacity: 1,874 pounds per the listing
  • Speed rating: Y

Pilot Sport All Season 4: fits and best for

The Pilot Sport All Season 4 fits a sporty sedan, coupe or performance crossover that needs sharp handling and real snow grip in one tyre. If you want the longest life or the quietest ride, the Defender 2 and the Primacy Tour A/S suit you better.

Pilot Sport All Season 4 pros and watch-outs

  • Sharpest handling in this guide
  • Best snow braking in its test class
  • 10 percent more snow traction than its predecessor
  • Strong dry and wet braking
  • First all-season tyre chosen for a Corvette
  • Shortest treadwear warranty here at 45,000 miles
  • No three-peak snowflake mark published
  • Noisier than a quiet touring tyre
  • Wears faster on heavy cars

Pilot Sport All Season 4: what owners report

Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the Pilot Sport All Season 4 keeps a sporty car sharp in the dry and still grips in snow, with braking that feels secure on cold wet roads. . Tire Wheel Guide Pilot Sport All Season 4 review

Other owners note the tyre is noisier than a touring tyre and wears faster, with some reporting around 28,000 miles on heavy use. . Drive 55 Pilot Sport All Season 4 review

Pilot Sport All Season 4: who should not buy

Do not buy the Pilot Sport All Season 4 if you want the longest tread life, because its 45,000-mile warranty is the shortest here. Do not buy it if you want the quietest ride, because a performance tyre is always firmer and louder than a touring tyre.

Pilot Sport All Season 4: pair it with

Pair it with a four-wheel alignment at fitting, because a performance tyre wears unevenly fast if the alignment is out.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Check pressures weekly in winter, because a performance tyre loses grip faster than a touring tyre when pressures drop. Warning Lights Reviews

Best for SUVs and Crossovers: MICHELIN CrossClimate2 All-Season Car Tire SUV CUV 245/45R17/XL 99V

Best for SUVs and Crossovers

Why the CrossClimate2 SUV 245/45R17 is our pick

The CrossClimate2 in SUV sizes is the same tyre as the overall pick, in the fitment your crossover needs. It carries the same three-peak mountain snowflake mark, the same V-shaped tread and thermally adaptive compound, and the same 60,000-mile treadwear warranty. The listing names a 245/45R17/XL 99V size with a 1,709 pound load capacity, and the tyre is listed for SUVs and crossovers as well as cars. If your car takes a 245/45R17 size, this is the CrossClimate2 to buy, with the same snow braking that beat the Defender 2 in Tire Rack testing.

CrossClimate2 SUV 245/45R17 key specs

  • Type: All-weather all-season tyre
  • Brand: Michelin
  • Model: CrossClimate2
  • Size: 245/45R17/XL 99V
  • Snow mark: Three-peak mountain snowflake
  • Treadwear warranty: 60,000 miles
  • UTQG: Not published on this listing
  • Compound: Thermally adaptive all-weather
  • Tread: Directional V-ramp pattern
  • Noise tuning: PIANO Noise Reduction Tuning
  • Load capacity: 1,709 pounds per the listing
  • Speed rating: V

CrossClimate2 SUV 245/45R17: fits and best for

The CrossClimate2 SUV size fits a crossover or SUV that takes a 245/45R17 tyre and drives through real winter weather. It suits family SUVs that need one tyre for the whole year. Check your door placard for the exact size first, because this listing covers one size only and other sizes sit on separate listings.

CrossClimate2 SUV 245/45R17 pros and watch-outs

  • Same snow grip as the overall pick
  • Three-peak snowflake certified
  • Built for heavier SUV loads
  • One tyre for the whole year
  • Strong wet and dry braking
  • One size only on this listing
  • Directional tread needs correct fitting rotation
  • Not a dedicated winter tyre for deep snow
  • UTQG not published on this listing

CrossClimate2 SUV 245/45R17: what owners report

Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the CrossClimate2 on a crossover feels secure in snow and slush, with the same confident braking owners report on cars. Drivers praise the year-round use on a family SUV. Tire Reviews Defender 2 versus CrossClimate 2

Other owners note the size on the listing must match the door placard exactly, and a few say the tyre needs a careful alignment to wear evenly on heavier SUVs. Tire Advise Defender 2 versus CrossClimate 2

CrossClimate2 SUV 245/45R17: who should not buy

Do not buy this listing if your SUV takes a different size, because the tyre on this listing is 245/45R17 only. Do not buy it as a substitute for a dedicated winter tyre if you drive through deep snow all winter.

CrossClimate2 SUV 245/45R17: pair it with

Pair it with a door-placard size check before you order, because the listing covers one size and the wrong size will not fit.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Use the size selector on the listing to find your exact size, because the CrossClimate2 comes in many sizes on separate listings. Best First Aid Kit Under 50

Spec comparison

SpecCrossClimate2 235/55R18Defender2 225/60R17Primacy Tour A/S 225/45R19Pilot Sport All Season 4CrossClimate2 SUV 245/45R17
Size235/55R18 100V225/60R17 99H225/45R19/XL 96W245/45ZR19/XL 102Y245/45R17/XL 99V
Snow markThree-peak mountain snowflakeM+S onlyM+S onlyM+S, no three-peak publishedThree-peak mountain snowflake
Treadwear warranty60,000 miles80,000 miles55,000 miles45,000 miles60,000 miles
UTQG640BA840540AA540AAANot published
Speed ratingVHWYV
Load capacity1,764 pounds1,709 pounds1,565 pounds1,874 pounds1,709 pounds
CompoundThermally adaptiveLong-life touringAdvanced performancePerformanceThermally adaptive
Noise tuningPIANO tuningNot publishedPIANO tuningNot publishedPIANO tuning
Test resultLed snow braking, Tire Rack testsBest all-season, Consumer Reports 2026Quietest tread among leadersFirst in snow braking in its classLed snow braking, Tire Rack tests
Best forRegular snowLong tread lifeQuiet touringPerformance in snowSUVs in snow
Tread patternDirectional V-rampTouring treadTouring treadPerformance treadDirectional V-ramp
Check PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price

How to fit and run all-season tyres on snow and ice

Start by checking the size on your door placard and matching it to the listing, because the tyre you buy covers one size only and the wrong size will not fit. Check the rotation arrows on a directional tyre such as the CrossClimate2, because the V-shaped tread only works when every tyre points the right way. Book a professional fitting for low-profile sizes, and check the load rating and speed rating against the placard at the same time. For the wider choice of all-season tyres at lower outlay, see our guide to Best All-Season Tires Under 100, and for the next step up, see Best All-Season Tires Under 200.

After fitting, set the pressures to the door placard figure, not the maximum on the sidewall, and check them monthly in winter, because cold air drops pressures and a soft tyre loses snow grip fast. Rotate the tyres every 6,000 to 8,000 miles so they wear evenly, and check the tread depth before the first winter, because a worn tyre loses what little snow grip it had faster than a new one. The Tire Reviews comparison of the Defender 2 and the CrossClimate 2 explains the snow-braking gap between the two and why the three-peak mark matters. Tire Reviews Defender 2 versus CrossClimate 2

On ice, the tyre is only part of the answer, so drive for the surface: brake early and gently, leave twice the gap you would on a dry road, and avoid sudden steering on glazed junctions. A three-peak tyre still slides on black ice, and no all-season tyre stops like a dedicated winter tyre on a frozen road. If your winters mean ice every week, consider a dedicated winter set for the coldest months. The Top Tire Review rematch of the CrossClimate 2 and the Defender 2 walks through the snow and ice trade-off in detail. Top Tire Review CrossClimate 2 versus Defender 2 rematch

Safety essentials

  • Never drive on a tyre with tread below the legal limit
  • Check pressures monthly, more often in winter
  • Replace tyres in pairs on the same axle
  • Never mix a three-peak tyre with a summer tyre
  • Check the rotation arrows on directional tyres
  • Book a professional fitting for low-profile tyres

Tyres are the only part of the car that touches the road, and on snow and ice that contact is everything. These rules keep the tyres working and the car stopping.

A digital tyre pressure gauge, so pressures stay at the placard figure — see our guide: Best All-Season Tires Under 100

A portable tyre inflator, so a slow leak never strands the car in winter — see our guide: Best All-Season Tires Under 200

A torque wrench for the lug nuts after the first 50 miles — see our guide: Best Adjustable Wrench

Troubleshooting

If the car slides in snow or on ice, check the tyres, the pressures and the size before you blame the tread pattern. AGM Batteries Cost

SymptomLikely causeFix
Car slides in snowWrong tyre for the winter, or worn treadFit a three-peak marked tyre with fresh tread
Tyre pressures drop in winterCold air lowers pressure by about 1 psi per 10 degreesCheck pressures monthly and top up to the placard figure
Uneven wear across the treadAlignment out, or no rotationBook an alignment and rotate every 6,000 miles
Tyre feels noisy on motorwaysPerformance tread, or wrong pressuresCheck pressures, or switch to a quiet touring tyre
Tyre does not fitWrong size on the listingMatch the door placard size before ordering
Directional tyre fitted backwardsRotation arrows ignored at fittingRefit the tyre with the arrows pointing forward

Who should NOT buy these

Do not buy an M+S tyre for regular snow. The M+S mark means only that the tread pattern looks like it should work in mud and snow, and it does not mean the tyre passed a snow test. Buy a three-peak mountain snowflake tyre if you drive on snow every week. AGM Batteries vs Flooded

Do not buy a long-life touring tyre for a snowy climate. The Defender 2 is the best tyre in this guide for miles, but it stops far longer on snow than the CrossClimate 2. Buy the tyre that matches your winter, not the one with the longest warranty. AGM Batteries vs Lead-Acid

Do not buy a tyre without checking the size. Every listing here covers one size only, and a 235/55R18 will not fit a car that takes a 245/45R17. Check the door placard, match the size, the load rating and the speed rating, then order. 12V Car Heaters Reviews Best Models

Do not buy a single tyre for a pair of worn tyres. A new tyre on one side and a worn tyre on the other pulls the car and wears unevenly, and in snow the grip difference is dangerous. Replace tyres in pairs on the same axle, and check the alignment at the same time. 12V Car Heaters vs AC

Final verdict

Best Overall for Snow: CrossClimate2 235/55R18 Check Price — The strongest snow tyre in this guide, with the severe-snow mark.

Best for Long Tread Life: Defender2 225/60R17 Check Price — The longest-lasting tyre in this guide, for drivers whose winters stay mild.

Best Quiet Touring: Primacy Tour A/S 225/45R19 Check Price — The quietest tyre in this guide, for premium cars in mild winters.

Best Performance in Snow: Pilot Sport All Season 4 Check Price — The performance pick, with sports handling and the best snow braking in its class.

Best for SUVs and Crossovers: CrossClimate2 SUV 245/45R17 Check Price — The same snow grip as the overall pick, in the size your SUV needs.

FAQ

Are all-season tyres good on snow and ice?

Some are and some are not. The CrossClimate2 carries the three-peak mountain snowflake mark and stops far shorter on snow than the Defender 2 in Tire Rack testing, and it stopped shorter on ice too. The Defender 2 and the Primacy Tour A/S carry only the M+S mark, so they handle a dusting of snow but are not the tyre for regular winter driving on snow and ice.

Which all-season tyre is best for snow and ice?

The CrossClimate2 is the best all-season tyre for snow and ice in this guide. It carries the three-peak mountain snowflake mark, its V-shaped tread bites snow, and it led snow braking in Tire Rack tests against the Defender 2. For an SUV or crossover, buy the CrossClimate2 in your size.

Do all-season tyres have the three-peak snowflake?

Only some do. The CrossClimate2 carries the three-peak mountain snowflake mark, which means it passed a regulated snow-traction test. The Defender 2, the Primacy Tour A/S and the Pilot Sport All Season 4 carry only the M+S mark, which does not mean they passed a snow test.

Can I use all-season tyres all year round?

Yes, if you buy a tyre with the three-peak mark such as the CrossClimate2. It is built as an all-weather tyre and covers the whole year with no seasonal swap. A dedicated winter tyre still wins in deep snow and mountain passes, but for most drivers one good all-weather tyre is the simpler answer.

How long do all-season tyres last?

The Defender 2 carries an 80,000-mile treadwear warranty and Consumer Reports estimated around 100,000 miles of tread life. The CrossClimate 2 warranty is 60,000 miles, the Primacy Tour A/S is 55,000 miles, and the Pilot Sport All Season 4 is 45,000 miles. Real life depends on driving style, pressures and rotation.

What size all-season tyre do I need for snow and ice?

Check the size on your door placard, because every listing here covers one size only. Match the size, the load rating and the speed rating exactly, and use the size selector on the listing to find your size. A tyre that fits a sedan will not fit an SUV.

Should I buy the CrossClimate2 or the Defender2?

Buy the CrossClimate2 if you drive regular snow and ice, because it stops far shorter on snow and carries the severe-snow mark. Buy the Defender 2 if your winters are mild and you drive big motorway miles, because it lasts longer and rides quietly. The choice is snow grip against tread life.

Do I need winter tyres if I have Michelin all-season tyres?

It depends on your winter. A CrossClimate2 with the three-peak mark handles regular snow and ice well enough for most drivers. If you drive through deep snow, ice and mountain passes all winter, a dedicated winter tyre still stops shorter and grips better than any all-season tyre.

How often should I rotate my all-season tyres?

Rotate them every 6,000 to 8,000 miles, or with every oil change, so they wear evenly and last the full warranty. Even wear matters most on a long-life tyre, because uneven wear throws away the miles you paid for. Check the rotation arrows on a directional tyre at the same time.

Sources

By Leo, Founder, WinchInsider

Leo researches winches and automotive accessories from maker documents, listing evidence and owner reports, and writes every guide so a first-time buyer can choose with confidence.

Related guides

MICHELIN CrossClimate2 All-Season Tire 235/55R18 100V

Leave a Comment