An all-season tire that handles ice is a promise that needs checking, because most all-season tires are fair-weather tires with a snow rating they never earned. The ones that work in winter carry a small mountain and snowflake symbol on the sidewall, and that symbol is the difference between a tire that grips and one that slides.
The tires in this guide are all-weather tires, which is the category between a conventional all-season and a dedicated winter tire. They carry the severe-snow rating, they grip on snow and light ice, and they stay on the car all year, but they are not a substitute for a dedicated winter tire in deep snow or on glare ice.
This guide compares five all-season tires for ice and snow, from the Michelin CrossClimate2 in two sizes to the Goodyear WeatherReady 2 and the Continental DWS06 PLUS, with the size warning that matters most: each listing is one size, so confirm your size from the door placard before you order.
The 30-second answer
Buy the Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17 99V XL All-Season Tire Check Price for the best all-round ice and snow grip. Buy the Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17 102H All-Season SUV Tire Check Price for the same tire in an SUV size. Buy the Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady 2 235/65R18 All-Season Radial Tire Check Price for the best wet-road handling in winter. Buy the Continental ExtremeContact DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19 100Y XL UHP All Season Tire Check Price for the best sporty sedan tire with winter grip. Buy the Michelin Defender2 225/60R17 99H All-Season Tire Check Price for the longest treadwear warranty here.
How we researched this guide
We profiled five all-season tires, checked Amazon listing data for each one through the Creators API, and reviewed independent tire tests and comparisons about snow braking, ice braking, wet handling and treadwear. Each listing is one size, so confirm your size from the door placard before you order. Where a listing does not publish a figure, we say so instead of guessing.
Our quick picks
Best Overall
Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17 99V XL All-Season Tire
Best for the best all-round ice and snow grip: a 245/45R17 all-weather tire with the severe-snow rating and a 60,000-mile treadwear warranty.
Best for SUVs
Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17 102H All-Season SUV Tire
Best for the same tire in an SUV size: a 225/65R17 CrossClimate2 with a 102H rating for crossovers and SUVs.
Best Goodyear
Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady 2 235/65R18 All-Season Radial Tire
Best for the best wet-road handling in winter: a 235/65R18 all-weather tire with the severe-snow rating and a 60,000-mile treadwear warranty.
Best for Sporty Sedans
Continental ExtremeContact DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19 100Y XL UHP All Season Tire
Best for the best sporty sedan tire with winter grip: a 275/35ZR19 ultra-high-performance all-season with strong wet and snow traction.
Best Long Tread Life
Michelin Defender2 225/60R17 99H All-Season Tire
Best for the longest treadwear warranty here: a 225/60R17 all-season tire for cars, crossovers, SUVs and minivans, with an 80,000-mile treadwear warranty.
Quick comparison
| Product | Size | Use | Warranty | Check Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17 99V XL All-Season Tire | 245/45R17 99V XL | Best all-round ice and snow grip | 60,000-mile treadwear | Check Price |
| Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17 102H All-Season SUV Tire | 225/65R17 102H | Same tire in an SUV size | 60,000-mile treadwear | Check Price |
| Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady 2 235/65R18 All-Season Radial Tire | 235/65R18, set of 1 | Best wet-road handling in winter | 60,000-mile treadwear | Check Price |
| Continental ExtremeContact DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19 100Y XL UHP All Season Tire | 275/35ZR19 100Y XL | Best sporty sedan tire with winter grip | Not published | Check Price |
| Michelin Defender2 225/60R17 99H All-Season Tire | 225/60R17 99H | Longest treadwear warranty here | 80,000-mile treadwear | Check Price |
How to choose an all-season tire for ice and snow
Check the 3PMSF symbol
Look for the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol on the sidewall, because it means the tire passed a severe-snow traction test and is not just a fair-weather all-season. A tire without the symbol may be fine in rain, but it has not proven itself in snow, so the symbol is the first check before any other feature. 12V Heater Review
Confirm your size first
Check the door placard for your size before you order, because each listing in this guide is one size only. A tire that is the wrong size cannot be fitted safely, however good its snow grip is, so the size, the load rating and the speed rating must all match your car. Best Car Buffer for Scratches
All-weather is not winter
Know that an all-weather tire is not a dedicated winter tire, because the all-weather category sits between a conventional all-season and a winter tire. It grips on snow and light ice and stays on the car all year, but it will not match a winter tire in deep snow or on glare ice, so match the tire to your winters. Best Car Buffer for Home Use
Snow grip versus wet grip
Decide whether snow or rain matters more, because the CrossClimate2 stops shorter on snow and ice per the tests, while the WeatherReady 2 laps the wet handling course faster. A driver in a snow-belt state should pick the snow tire, while a driver in a wet, mild winter should pick the wet tire. 12V Adapters Reviews for Cars
Treadwear warranty
Check the treadwear warranty, because it tells you how long the maker expects the tire to last. The Defender2 carries an 80,000-mile warranty and the CrossClimate2 and WeatherReady 2 carry 60,000 miles, so the warranty is a useful guide to longevity when the snow grip is close. 12V Adapters Reviews Best
Buy four, not two
Buy a full set of four in the same size, because mixing a winter-grip tire with an old all-season leaves the car with different grip at each end. A matched set stops and turns evenly, and the car behaves predictably in the snow, which is the whole point of buying a winter-capable tire. 12V Adapters for Beginners Guide
All-season tires for ice and snow by budget
| Tier | What you get | Example pick |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest outlay | An all-season tire with a long treadwear warranty for family cars | Michelin Defender2 |
| Mid-range | An all-weather tire with the severe-snow rating for snow-belt states | Michelin CrossClimate2 |
| Wet winters | An all-weather tire with the best wet-road handling | Goodyear WeatherReady 2 |
Types of all-season tires for ice and snow
| Type | How it works | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| All-weather tire | Carries the severe-snow rating, stays on all year | A driver in a snow-belt state | Not a dedicated winter tire |
| Conventional all-season | No severe-snow rating, fair-weather grip | A driver in a mild climate | Slides on snow and ice |
| Ultra-high-performance all-season | Handling first, winter grip second | A sporty sedan owner | Less snow grip than an all-weather |
| Long-life all-season | Built for treadwear and longevity | A family car that needs a tire that lasts | Snow grip behind the snow picks |
Detailed reviews
Each tire below was checked against its Amazon listing data and the independent tire tests behind it, with the size and the snow rating answered first, because the size is the part that decides whether the tire fits your car.
Best Overall: Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17 99V XL All-Season Tire
Best Overall
Why the Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17 is our pick
The Michelin CrossClimate2 is the overall pick because it is the tire that independent tests keep putting at the top for winter grip, and this listing is the 245/45R17 size with a 99V XL load and speed rating. Michelin classifies the CrossClimate2 as an all-weather grand-touring tire, which sits between a conventional all-season and a dedicated winter tire, and it carries the 3PMSF severe-snow symbol on the sidewall. In three independent tests that ran both the CrossClimate2 and the Goodyear WeatherReady 2, the Michelin finished ahead twice. The treadwear warranty is 60,000 miles per the maker, and the directional tread cuts through snow and standing water.
Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17 key specs
- Type: All-weather grand-touring tire
- Size: 245/45R17 99V XL
- Snow rating: 3PMSF severe-snow
- Treadwear warranty: 60,000 miles
- Tread: Directional, V-shaped
- Use: Year-round, all-weather
- Winter: Snow and light ice, not deep snow
- Load: XL
- Warranty: 60,000-mile treadwear
- Listing: Verified
Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17: fits and best for
This tire fits a driver in a snow-belt state who wants one set of tires for the whole year, with real winter grip. It suits a sedan or coupe on a 245/45R17 size, and a driver who faces snow and light ice but not the deep snow that needs a dedicated winter tire.
Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17 pros and watch-outs
- Best winter grip in independent tests
- 3PMSF severe-snow rating
- 60,000-mile treadwear warranty
- Directional tread cuts snow and water
- Year-round, no seasonal swap
- Not a dedicated winter tire for deep snow
- One size only, confirm your size
- Directional tread, rotation matters
- Warranty per the maker
Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17: what owners report
Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the CrossClimate2 is the tire that changes winter driving, because the car stops and turns on snow where the old all-seasons slid, and the tire stays quiet on dry roads in summer.
Owners also report the directional tread handles standing water well, though a few note it is not a substitute for a winter tire in deep snow. A CrossClimate2 review calls it the closest thing to a true do-everything tire, with a severe-snow rating and three winters of use.
Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17: who should not buy
Do not buy this if you live where winters bring deep snow or glare ice every week, because an all-weather tire is not a dedicated winter tire. A Michelin X-Ice Snow or a Bridgestone Blizzak is the right buy then.
Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17: pair it with
Pair it with a full set of four in the same size, and check the door placard for your size before you order, because this listing is one size only.
We may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Check the sidewall for the 3PMSF symbol when the tires arrive, so the severe-snow rating is confirmed before the install. 12V Adapters Review Amazon
Best for SUVs: Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17 102H All-Season SUV Tire
Best for SUVs
Why the Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17 is our pick
The Michelin CrossClimate2 in 225/65R17 is the SUV pick because it is the same tire as the overall pick, in the size that fits crossovers and SUVs. The listing describes a passenger SUV tire with a 102H load and speed rating, and the same 3PMSF severe-snow rating applies, because the rating belongs to the tire design rather than the size. An independent review of the CrossClimate2 notes the same strengths here: a directional tread that cuts snow and standing water, a 60,000-mile treadwear warranty, and winter grip that beats most premium all-seasons. For an SUV that needs one set of tires for the whole year, this is the size to buy.
Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17 key specs
- Type: All-weather grand-touring tire
- Size: 225/65R17 102H
- Snow rating: 3PMSF severe-snow
- Treadwear warranty: 60,000 miles
- Tread: Directional, V-shaped
- Use: Year-round, all-weather
- Fit: Crossovers and SUVs
- Load: 102H
- Warranty: 60,000-mile treadwear
- Listing: Verified
Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17: fits and best for
This tire fits a crossover or SUV owner who wants the CrossClimate2 in the right size for their vehicle. It suits a family SUV that faces snow and light ice in winter, and a driver who wants one set of tires for the whole year.
Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17 pros and watch-outs
- Same winter grip as the overall pick
- 3PMSF severe-snow rating
- 60,000-mile treadwear warranty
- SUV size with a 102H rating
- Year-round, no seasonal swap
- Not a dedicated winter tire for deep snow
- One size only, confirm your size
- Directional tread, rotation matters
- Warranty per the maker
Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17: what owners report
Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the SUV size CrossClimate2 is the tire that makes a crossover feel sure-footed in snow, because the car stops and turns where the factory tires slid, and the ride stays comfortable on dry roads.
Owners also report the tire is quiet on the highway, though a few note the size must be confirmed from the placard. A head-to-head comparison puts the CrossClimate2 ahead of the WeatherReady 2 in two of three shared tests, with shorter snow and ice stops.
Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17: who should not buy
Do not buy this if your SUV takes a different size, because this listing is 225/65R17 only. Check the door placard for your size, and buy the CrossClimate2 in that size instead.
Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17: pair it with
Pair it with a full set of four in the same size, and check the load rating against your SUV, because the 102H rating must match the vehicle.
We may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Check the door placard for the size and the load rating before you order, so the tires that arrive are the tires your SUV needs. 12V Adapters Alternative for LED Lights
Best Goodyear: Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady 2 235/65R18 All-Season Radial Tire
Best Goodyear
Why the Goodyear WeatherReady 2 235/65R18 is our pick
The Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady 2 is the Goodyear pick because it is the tire that wins the wet-road argument in the independent tests, lapping the wet handling course faster than the CrossClimate2 in all three shared tests. The listing describes a 235/65R18 all-season radial tire, sold as a set of one, with the 3PMSF severe-snow rating on the sidewall and a 60,000-mile treadwear warranty per the maker. An independent review notes the tire feels quieter on the highway and offers strong hydroplaning resistance in deep standing water, with capable grip in light snow and ice. For a driver whose winters are wet more than deep, this is the pick that handles the rain best.
Goodyear WeatherReady 2 235/65R18 key specs
- Type: All-weather tire
- Size: 235/65R18
- Sold as: Set of 1
- Snow rating: 3PMSF severe-snow
- Treadwear warranty: 60,000 miles
- Use: Year-round, all-weather
- Winter: Light snow and ice
- Wet: Strong wet handling per tests
- Warranty: 60,000-mile treadwear
- Listing: Verified
Goodyear WeatherReady 2 235/65R18: fits and best for
This tire fits a driver whose winters are wet and mild, with rain and light snow rather than deep drifts. It suits a crossover or SUV on a 235/65R18 size, and a driver who values wet-road handling and a quiet ride over the last bit of snow grip.
Goodyear WeatherReady 2 235/65R18 pros and watch-outs
- Best wet handling in shared tests
- 3PMSF severe-snow rating
- 60,000-mile treadwear warranty
- Strong hydroplaning resistance
- Quiet on the highway
- Sold as a set of one, buy four
- Not a dedicated winter tire for deep snow
- One size only, confirm your size
- Snow grip behind the CrossClimate2 per tests
Goodyear WeatherReady 2 235/65R18: what owners report
Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the WeatherReady 2 is the tire that feels calm in the rain, because the wet grip is strong and the car tracks straight through standing water, and the snow grip is enough for a mild winter.
Owners also report the tire is quieter than the Michelin on the highway, though a few note the deep-snow grip is a step behind. A WeatherReady 2 review notes strong wet grip, a quiet ride and a 60,000-mile warranty, with capable light snow and ice performance.
Goodyear WeatherReady 2 235/65R18: who should not buy
Do not buy this if your winters bring deep snow every week, because the WeatherReady 2 trails the CrossClimate2 on snow per the tests. The CrossClimate2 is the deeper-snow pick.
Goodyear WeatherReady 2 235/65R18: pair it with
Pair it with a full set of four, because this listing is a set of one, and check the door placard for your size before you order.
We may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Buy four, not one, and check the sidewall for the 3PMSF symbol when the tires arrive, so the severe-snow rating is confirmed before the install. 12V Adapters Alternative to USB
Best for Sporty Sedans: Continental ExtremeContact DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19 100Y XL UHP All Season Tire
Best for Sporty Sedans
Why the Continental DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19 is our pick
The Continental ExtremeContact DWS06 PLUS is the sporty pick because it is an ultra-high-performance all-season tire that keeps its winter grip, and this listing is the 275/35ZR19 size with a 100Y XL rating. The listing describes a UHP all-season passenger tire, and an independent roundup names the DWS06 PLUS its best pick for sporty sedans, with a wide footprint and a low aspect ratio that prioritise dry grip and steering response. Owner reports praise the dry traction and the wet performance, with strong marks in snow and acceptable winter performance for an all-season. For a sporty sedan that needs handling in summer and grip in winter, this is the one.
Continental DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19 key specs
- Type: Ultra-high-performance all-season
- Size: 275/35ZR19 100Y XL
- Snow rating: Per the maker range
- Use: Year-round, all-weather
- Fit: Sporty sedans, performance cars
- Tread: All-season, UHP
- Load: XL
- Warranty: Not published
- Listing: Verified
Continental DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19: fits and best for
This tire fits a sporty sedan owner who wants handling and steering response in summer, with winter grip that covers snow and light ice. It suits a performance car on a 275/35ZR19 size, and a driver who accepts that a UHP all-season is not a dedicated winter tire.
Continental DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19 pros and watch-outs
- Best handling in this guide
- Strong wet traction and hydroplaning resistance
- Good snow traction for an all-season
- Wide footprint, low aspect ratio
- Year-round, no seasonal swap
- Not a dedicated winter tire for deep snow
- One size only, confirm your size
- Warranty not published
- Low profile, harsher ride on rough roads
Continental DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19: what owners report
Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the DWS06 PLUS is the tire that makes a sporty sedan feel sharp in the dry and sure in the wet, with snow traction that surprises for an ultra-high-performance tire.
Owners also report the tire is a strong alternative to a dearer Michelin without giving up much, though a few note it is not a track tire. Tire Rack owner reports praise the DWS06 PLUS for dry traction, wet performance and snow traction, with strong treadwear.
Continental DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19: who should not buy
Do not buy this if you want the deepest snow grip in this guide, because the CrossClimate2 stops shorter on snow per the tests. The DWS06 PLUS is the handling pick, not the snow pick.
Continental DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19: pair it with
Pair it with a full set of four in the same size, and check the door placard and the load rating before you order, because this listing is one size only.
We may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Check the load rating against your car, because the 100Y XL rating must match the vehicle. Best ATV Winch
Best Long Tread Life: Michelin Defender2 225/60R17 99H All-Season Tire
Best Long Tread Life
Why the Michelin Defender2 225/60R17 is our pick
The Michelin Defender2 is the long-life pick because it carries the longest treadwear warranty in this guide at 80,000 miles per the maker, and an independent roundup names it its best overall all-season tire for cars and SUVs. The listing describes a 225/60R17 all-season tire with a 99H rating, for cars, crossovers, SUVs and minivans, so the fit covers most family vehicles. The Defender2 is the tire for a driver who values longevity over the last bit of snow grip, because the tread is built to last and the all-season design covers rain and light snow. For a family car that needs a tire that goes the distance, this is the pick.
Michelin Defender2 225/60R17 key specs
- Type: All-season tire
- Size: 225/60R17 99H
- Snow rating: All-season, per the maker range
- Treadwear warranty: 80,000 miles
- Fit: Cars, CUV, SUV and minivans
- Use: Year-round
- Load: 99H
- Warranty: 80,000-mile treadwear
- Listing: Verified
Michelin Defender2 225/60R17: fits and best for
This tire fits a family car owner who wants a tire that lasts, with all-season grip for rain and light snow. It suits a sedan, crossover, SUV or minivan on a 225/60R17 size, and a driver who values tread life over the deepest snow grip.
Michelin Defender2 225/60R17 pros and watch-outs
- Longest treadwear warranty in this guide
- Best overall all-season per a roundup
- Fits cars, CUV, SUV and minivans
- Year-round, no seasonal swap
- Michelin build and support
- Snow grip behind the CrossClimate2
- Not a dedicated winter tire
- One size only, confirm your size
- Severe-snow rating not stated in the listing
Michelin Defender2 225/60R17: what owners report
Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the Defender2 is the tire that lasts, because the tread wears slowly and the car stays quiet on the highway, and the all-season grip covers rain and light snow well.
Owners also report the tire is the natural fit for a wide range of crossovers and SUVs, though a few note the snow grip is a step behind the CrossClimate2. A WikiTire all-season guide names the Defender2 its best overall pick, for its fitment range and the maker reputation for durability.
Michelin Defender2 225/60R17: who should not buy
Do not buy this if you need the deepest snow and ice grip in this guide, because the Defender2 is the longevity pick, not the snow pick. The CrossClimate2 stops shorter on snow and ice per the tests.
Michelin Defender2 225/60R17: pair it with
Pair it with a full set of four in the same size, and check the door placard for your size before you order, because this listing is one size only.
We may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Check the door placard for the size and the load rating before you order, so the tires that arrive are the tires your car needs. Best Jump Starter
Spec comparison
| Spec | Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17 | Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17 | Goodyear WeatherReady 2 235/65R18 | Continental DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19 | Michelin Defender2 225/60R17 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Size | 245/45R17 | 225/65R17 | 235/65R18 | 275/35ZR19 | 225/60R17 |
| Load and speed | 99V XL | 102H | Per the maker range | 100Y XL | 99H |
| Snow rating | 3PMSF | 3PMSF | 3PMSF | Per the maker range | Per the maker range |
| Treadwear warranty | 60,000 miles | 60,000 miles | 60,000 miles | Not published | 80,000 miles |
| Tread | Directional V-shaped | Directional V-shaped | All-weather | UHP all-season | All-season |
| Sold as | Set of 1 | Set of 1 | Set of 1 | Set of 1 | Set of 1 |
| Fit | Sedan, coupe | Crossover, SUV | Crossover, SUV | Sporty sedan | Car, CUV, SUV, minivan |
| Winter use | Snow and light ice | Snow and light ice | Light snow and ice | Snow, acceptable | Light snow |
| Use | Year-round | Year-round | Year-round | Year-round | Year-round |
| Warranty | 60,000-mile treadwear | 60,000-mile treadwear | 60,000-mile treadwear | Not published | 80,000-mile treadwear |
| Check Price | Check Price | Check Price | Check Price | Check Price | Check Price |
Installation basics
Check the door placard for your size, load rating and speed rating before you order, because each listing in this guide is one size only. A tire that is the wrong size cannot be fitted safely, however good its snow grip is, so the placard is the authority, not the listing title. A tire comparison guide scores the CrossClimate2 ahead of the WeatherReady 2 on snow, with the test results behind the scores
Have the tires fitted by a shop that balances and aligns the car, because a new set of tires deserves a fresh balance and an alignment check. Ask the shop to check the sidewall for the 3PMSF symbol when the tires arrive, so the severe-snow rating is confirmed before the install. A CrossClimate2 review explains the 3PMSF rating and why an all-weather tire is not a dedicated winter tire
Check the tread depth and the pressure every month in winter, because a tire that is worn or underinflated loses its snow grip first. Keep the pressure at the placard figure, not the sidewall maximum, and rotate the tires on the schedule the maker gives. A WeatherReady 2 review covers the 3PMSF rating, the 60,000-mile warranty and the light snow and ice performance
Safety essentials
- Buy four tires in the same size, never mix winter-grip and old tires.
- Check the pressure at the placard figure, not the sidewall maximum.
- Check the tread depth every month in winter.
- Slow down on ice, because no all-season tire grips glare ice like a winter tire.
- Keep a safe following distance in snow, because stopping distances grow.
- Check the sidewall for the 3PMSF symbol when the tires arrive.
An all-weather tire grips on snow and light ice, but it is not a dedicated winter tire. Drive for the conditions, not for the rating on the sidewall.
Anker 320 24W Dual-USB Mini Car Charger, to keep a phone charged while you work.
LISEN 48W USB C Car Charger Adapter 2 Pack, so a phone and a second device stay charged.
UGREEN 130W USB C Car Charger with Cable, for fast charging on long days away from home.
Troubleshooting
Most tire faults are pressure or wear faults, and the fix is usually at a gauge or a rotation rather than in the tire itself. Best Automotive Multimeters vs Watts
| Symptom | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Car slides on ice | All-weather tire, not a winter tire | Slow down and fit dedicated winter tires for deep snow. |
| Uneven wear | Alignment off or pressure wrong | Check the alignment and set the pressure to the placard. |
| Vibration at speed | Wheels out of balance | Have the shop balance the wheels again. |
| Tires wear fast | Pressure low or alignment off | Check the pressure monthly and rotate on schedule. |
| Noise on the highway | Tread pattern or wear | Check the tread depth and the rotation direction. |
| Tire will not fit | Wrong size ordered | Check the door placard and order the right size. |
Who should NOT buy these
You live where winters bring deep snow every week. An all-weather tire is not a dedicated winter tire, because it will not match a winter tire in deep snow or on glare ice. If your winters are that hard, buy a dedicated winter tire such as a Michelin X-Ice Snow or a Bridgestone Blizzak, and keep the all-season set for summer. Best Automotive Borescope for Mechanics
Your car takes a different size. Every listing in this guide is one size only, because a tire that is the wrong size cannot be fitted safely. Check the door placard for your size, load rating and speed rating, and buy the tire in that size, even if it is not the size listed here. Best Adjustable Wrench
You want a tire that never needs a seasonal swap and grips like a winter tire. No tire does both, because an all-weather tire trades a little winter grip for year-round use, and a winter tire trades summer wear for ice grip. Pick the tire that matches your winters, and accept the trade that comes with it. Best All-Season Tires Under 100
You only drive in a mild climate with no snow. A severe-snow tire is more than a mild climate needs, because the winter grip is wasted where it never snows. A conventional all-season with a long treadwear warranty, such as the Defender2, is the better buy then. Best All-Season Tires Under 200
Final verdict
Best Overall: Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17 Check Price — the best all-round ice and snow grip here.
Best for SUVs: Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17 Check Price — the same tire in an SUV size.
Best Goodyear: Goodyear WeatherReady 2 235/65R18 Check Price — the best wet-road handling in winter here.
Best for Sporty Sedans: Continental DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19 Check Price — the best sporty sedan tire with winter grip.
Best Long Tread Life: Michelin Defender2 225/60R17 Check Price — the longest treadwear warranty here.
FAQ
Are all-season tires good on ice?
An all-weather tire with the severe-snow rating grips on light ice, but no all-season tire grips glare ice like a dedicated winter tire. The CrossClimate2 stopped shorter on ice than the WeatherReady 2 in shared tests, but both are all-weather tires, not winter tires. If your winters bring deep snow or glare ice every week, buy a dedicated winter tire instead.
What does the 3PMSF symbol mean on a tire?
The three-peak mountain snowflake symbol means the tire passed a severe-snow traction test, with significantly better traction on medium-packed snow than a reference all-season tire. It is the same severe-snow rating that winter tires carry, and it is the mark that separates a true all-weather tire from a fair-weather all-season. Check the sidewall for the symbol when the tires arrive.
Is the Michelin CrossClimate2 a winter tire?
No, it is an all-weather tire, which sits between a conventional all-season and a dedicated winter tire. It carries the severe-snow rating, grips on snow and light ice, and stays on the car all year, but it will not match a dedicated winter tire in deep snow or on glare ice. For mixed-weather drivers it is the closest thing to a do-everything tire.
What size tire do I need?
The size on the door placard, because each listing in this guide is one size only. The placard gives the size, the load rating and the speed rating your car needs, and a tire that does not match cannot be fitted safely. Check the placard before you order, and buy a full set of four in the same size.
Should I buy two or four winter-capable tires?
Four, because mixing a winter-grip tire with an old all-season leaves the car with different grip at each end. A matched set stops and turns evenly, and the car behaves predictably in the snow, which is the whole point of buying a winter-capable tire. Never put winter-grip tires on only one axle.
How long do all-season tires last?
The treadwear warranty is the guide: the Defender2 carries an 80,000-mile warranty and the CrossClimate2 and WeatherReady 2 carry 60,000 miles. Real life depends on driving style, alignment and pressure, so check the tread depth every month in winter and rotate the tires on the schedule the maker gives.
Can I use all-season tires all year round?
Yes, that is the point of an all-weather tire, because it stays on the car in summer and winter without a seasonal swap. The trade is that it will not match a dedicated winter tire in deep snow, or a summer tire in dry grip, so match the tire to your climate and accept the trade that comes with it.
What is the difference between the CrossClimate2 and the WeatherReady 2?
The CrossClimate2 stops shorter on snow and ice per the shared tests, while the WeatherReady 2 laps the wet handling course faster and feels quieter on the highway. Both carry the severe-snow rating and a 60,000-mile warranty, so the choice is about your winters: snow-belt drivers should pick the Michelin, and wet-winter drivers should pick the Goodyear.
Do I need winter tires if I have all-season tires?
It depends on your winters. An all-weather tire with the severe-snow rating covers snow and light ice for most drivers, but a dedicated winter tire is the right buy if your winters bring deep snow or glare ice every week. Check the 3PMSF symbol on your current tires, and buy winter tires if the symbol is missing and the snow is deep.
Sources
- Amazon listing, Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17, ASIN B0914GSZW9
- Amazon listing, Michelin CrossClimate2 225/65R17, ASIN B08WRKX1H2
- Amazon listing, Goodyear WeatherReady 2 235/65R18, ASIN B0DLX2CJHC
- Amazon listing, Continental DWS06 PLUS 275/35ZR19, ASIN B08TQBLNF3
- Amazon listing, Michelin Defender2 225/60R17, ASIN B0B4F3QKJR
- Tyre Reviews WeatherReady 2 vs CrossClimate 2
- TireWheelGuide CrossClimate2 vs WeatherReady 2
- The Tire Reviews Michelin CrossClimate2 review
- The Tire Reviews Goodyear WeatherReady 2 review
- WikiTire best all-season tires for cars and SUVs
- Tire Rack Continental ExtremeContact DWS06 PLUS
By Leo, Founder, WinchInsider
Leo researches winches and automotive accessories from maker documents, listing evidence and owner reports, and writes every guide so a first-time buyer can choose with confidence.
Related guides
- Best Garage Security Cameras Under 100
- Best Garage Storage
- Best Hard Tonneau Cover Under 500
- Best Mud Flaps
- Best Performance Monitors Under 100
- Best Storage Bins
Michelin CrossClimate2 245/45R17 99V XL All-Season Tire