Alternatives to Air Conditioning

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you.

An air conditioner is not the only way to stay cool, and in dry heat it is not always the best way. A swamp cooler uses a fraction of the power, a tower fan moves air without water, and both cost far less to run through a long summer.

The catch is climate. Evaporative cooling works by adding moisture to dry air, so it shines in a desert and fails in humidity. A fan works anywhere, but it moves air without dropping the temperature. Knowing which one fits your air is the whole decision.

This guide compares four alternatives to air conditioning, from a large evaporative cooler to a tower fan, so you can pick the cooling that matches your climate, your room and your power bill. A cooler that matches your climate pays for itself in one summer; a cooler that fights your climate is a fan with a water tank.

The 30-second answer

Buy the Hessaire MC37M Evaporative Cooler, 3,100 CFM Check Price for the largest spaces. Buy the Hessaire MC18M Evaporative Cooler, 1,300 CFM Check Price for a mid-size room or patio. Buy the Honeywell CL30XC Indoor Portable Evaporative Air Cooler, 525 CFM Check Price for a bedroom or office. Buy the Lasko T42951 42 Inch Wind Curve Tower Fan with Remote Check Price for humid rooms where water cooling cannot work.

How we researched this guide

We profiled four cooling alternatives, checked Amazon listing data for each one through the Creators API, and reviewed maker pages and owner reports in retailer reviews about airflow, coverage, water use and noise. Where a listing does not publish a figure, we say so instead of guessing.

Our quick picks

Best Overall

Hessaire MC37M Evaporative Cooler, 3,100 CFM

Best for large spaces: 3,100 CFM of airflow over 950 square feet, with a 10.3-gallon tank for long runs.

Best Mid-Size

Hessaire MC18M Evaporative Cooler, 1,300 CFM

Best for a mid-size space: 1,300 CFM over 500 square feet, with a 4.8-gallon tank and a 16 lb body you can move alone.

Best Indoor Room Cooler

Honeywell CL30XC Indoor Portable Evaporative Air Cooler, 525 CFM

Best for a bedroom or office: 525 CFM over 320 square feet, with an ice compartment, a remote and a quiet fan.

Best Tower Fan

Lasko T42951 42 Inch Wind Curve Tower Fan with Remote

Best for moving air without water: a 42-inch oscillating tower fan with a remote, for rooms where evaporative cooling cannot work.

Quick comparison

ProductCoolingUseWarrantyCheck Price
Hessaire MC37M Evaporative Cooler, 3,100 CFM3,100 CFM, 950 sq ftLarge spaces in dry heatNot publishedCheck Price
Hessaire MC18M Evaporative Cooler, 1,300 CFM1,300 CFM, 500 sq ftMid-size rooms and patiosNot publishedCheck Price
Honeywell CL30XC Indoor Portable Evaporative Air Cooler, 525 CFM525 CFM, 320 sq ftBedrooms and officesNot publishedCheck Price
Lasko T42951 42 Inch Wind Curve Tower Fan with Remote42 in tower fan, 3 speedsHumid rooms and bedroomsNot publishedCheck Price

How to choose an alternative to air conditioning

Cooling method

An evaporative cooler drops the air temperature by evaporating water, which works in dry heat and fails in humidity. A tower fan moves air without changing its temperature, which works anywhere but cools less. Pick evaporative cooling for dry air, and a fan for humid air. Best Automotive Borescope for Mechanics

Coverage area

Match the cooler to the room: 525 CFM suits a bedroom, 1,300 CFM suits a mid-size room or patio, and 3,100 CFM suits a garage or workshop. A cooler that is too small for the space will run all day and never catch up. Best Adjustable Wrench

Water tank

A bigger tank means fewer refills, but it also means a heavier unit. A 10.3-gallon tank runs for hours in a large cooler, while a 4.8-gallon tank suits a mid-size unit you move often. Check the tank size against how long you run the cooler each day. Best All-Season Tires Under 100

Power use

An evaporative cooler uses a fan and a small pump, so it draws far less power than an air conditioner, and a tower fan draws less still. If the power bill is the reason you are avoiding air conditioning, check the wattage before you buy. Best All-Season Tires Under 200

Noise

A cooler that runs all day must be quiet enough to live with. Check the decibel rating: 53.4 dB is conversation level, while a louder unit will wear on you in a bedroom. A tower fan on low speed is usually the quietest option here. Best Garage Security Cameras Under 100

Portability

A cooler with wheels moves between a garage, a patio and a bedroom, while a heavy unit stays where you put it. A 16 lb cooler moves alone, a large cooler needs two people or a permanent spot. Match the weight to how often you move it. Best Garage Storage

Cooling alternatives by budget

TierWhat you getExample pick
Tower fanA slim fan for moving air in humid rooms, with no water or tank.Lasko T42951 tower fan
Mid-size evaporativeA portable cooler for one room or a small patio in dry heat.Hessaire MC18M
Large evaporativeA high-airflow cooler for a garage, workshop or large room.Hessaire MC37M
Indoor room coolerA quiet cooler with a remote and an ice compartment, for bedrooms.Honeywell CL30XC

Cooling alternatives compared

TypeHow it worksBest forWatch out for
Evaporative coolerDraws hot dry air through wet media and cools it.Dry climates, garages and patios.Fails in humid air; needs water.
Tower fanMoves air across a room without changing its temperature.Humid rooms and bedrooms.Does not lower air temperature.
Portable air conditionerCools and dehumidifies, but needs a vent hose.Humid climates where cooling matters.Costs more to run; needs a window.
Whole-house fanPulls cool evening air through the whole house.Dry climates with cool nights.Needs a cool night to work.
Misting fanA fan that sprays a fine mist into the air.Patios and outdoor areas.Wets everything nearby; needs water.

Detailed reviews

Four alternatives, four climates: large, mid-size, indoor, and humid. The three evaporative coolers cover large, mid-size and indoor spaces, and the tower fan covers humid rooms. Each review below covers the airflow, the coverage, what owners report, and who should skip it.

Best Overall: Hessaire MC37M Evaporative Cooler, 3,100 CFM

Best Overall

Why the Hessaire MC37M is our pick

The Hessaire MC37M is the overall pick because it cools the largest area in this guide. It moves 3,100 cubic feet of air per minute over up to 950 square feet, and its 10.3-gallon tank runs for hours without a refill. The evaporative design draws hot, dry air through water-soaked media and drops the temperature as the water evaporates, which uses far less power than an air conditioner. It suits a garage, a workshop, a patio or a large room in a dry climate. For the biggest cooling job without air conditioning, this is the cooler to buy first. It is the cooler for a workshop where the doors stay open and the air stays dry.

Hessaire MC37M key specs

  • Type: Portable evaporative cooler
  • Airflow: 3,100 CFM
  • Coverage: Up to 950 sq ft
  • Water tank: 10.3 gal
  • Power: Low, fan and pump only
  • Use: Garage, workshop, patio and large rooms
  • Climate: Best in hot, dry air
  • Sold as: Single unit
  • Listing: Verified

Hessaire MC37M: fits and best for

This cooler fits a driver or homeowner cooling a large space in dry heat: a garage, a workshop, a patio or a big room. It suits anyone who wants real cooling without an air conditioner, and who lives where the air is dry enough for evaporation to work.

Hessaire MC37M pros and watch-outs

  • Largest coverage in this guide
  • 3,100 CFM of airflow
  • 10.3-gallon tank, long runs
  • Uses far less power than AC
  • Wheels for moving between spaces
  • Needs dry air to work well
  • Large unit, needs floor space
  • Tank needs regular refilling
  • Warranty not published in the listing

Hessaire MC37M: what owners report

Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the MC37M drops the temperature noticeably in a garage or workshop, and the big tank means fewer refills during a long hot day.

Owners also report it struggles in humid air, which is expected from evaporative cooling. BestAdvisor lists the MC37M among its best evaporative coolers.

Hessaire MC37M: who should not buy

Do not buy this if you live in a humid climate, because evaporative cooling adds moisture to air that is already wet. A tower fan or a portable air conditioner suits humid rooms better.

Hessaire MC37M: pair it with

Pair it with an open window or door on the far side of the room, so the cooled air flows through instead of building up humidity.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Fill the tank and run the pump for a few minutes before the fan: wet media cools far better than dry media. Best Hard Tonneau Cover Under 500

Best Mid-Size: Hessaire MC18M Evaporative Cooler, 1,300 CFM

Best Mid-Size

Why the Hessaire MC18M is our pick

The Hessaire MC18M is the mid-size pick because it balances cooling power with portability. It moves 1,300 cubic feet of air per minute over up to 500 square feet, and its 4.8-gallon tank supplies the water for hours of cooling. The unit weighs 16 lb, runs at 53.4 dB on its two-speed fan, and has wheels so one person can move it between a garage, a patio and a bedroom. Roundups call it the most versatile portable evaporative cooler on the market. For a single room or a small outdoor area in dry heat, this is the cooler to buy. It is the cooler for a patio where the evening stays hot and the air stays dry.

Hessaire MC18M key specs

  • Type: Portable evaporative cooler
  • Airflow: 1,300 CFM
  • Coverage: Up to 500 sq ft
  • Water tank: 4.8 gal
  • Weight: 16 lb
  • Noise: 53.4 dB
  • Speeds: 2-speed fan
  • Use: Rooms, patios and small outdoor areas
  • Sold as: Single unit
  • Listing: Verified

Hessaire MC18M: fits and best for

This cooler fits a homeowner cooling one room, a small patio or a home workshop in dry heat. It suits anyone who wants real evaporative cooling in a unit light enough to move alone.

Hessaire MC18M pros and watch-outs

  • 1,300 CFM for 500 sq ft
  • Light at 16 lb, with wheels
  • 4.8-gallon tank
  • Two-speed fan, quiet at 53.4 dB
  • Most versatile portable cooler per roundups
  • Needs dry air to work well
  • Smaller coverage than the MC37M
  • Tank needs refilling
  • Warranty not published in the listing

Hessaire MC18M: what owners report

Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the MC18M is easy to move between rooms, and the two-speed fan is quiet enough for conversation.

Owners also report it cools a patio well in dry heat. Noahs Notation names the MC18M its best evaporative cooler.

Hessaire MC18M: who should not buy

Do not buy this if you need to cool a large garage or workshop, because 500 square feet is its limit. The MC37M suits large spaces better.

Hessaire MC18M: pair it with

Pair it with a hose or a bucket nearby, so refilling the 4.8-gallon tank is quick.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Run the cooler for 30 minutes to dry before storing it: a damp cooler grows musty. Best Mud Flaps

Best Indoor Room Cooler: Honeywell CL30XC Indoor Portable Evaporative Air Cooler, 525 CFM

Best Indoor Room Cooler

Why the Honeywell CL30XC is our pick

The Honeywell CL30XC is the indoor pick because it is made for rooms, not workshops. It moves 525 cubic feet of air per minute over up to 320 square feet, and it adds an ice compartment for a colder blast, a remote control, and a washable dust filter. The 7.9-gallon tank runs for hours, and the unit is quiet enough for a bedroom or an office. Roundups list it as a solid indoor evaporative cooler for medium rooms. For a bedroom, a home office or a living room in dry heat, this is the cooler to buy. It is the cooler for a bedroom where a quiet fan and a remote matter more than raw airflow.

Honeywell CL30XC key specs

  • Type: Indoor portable evaporative cooler
  • Airflow: 525 CFM
  • Coverage: Up to 320 sq ft
  • Water tank: 7.9 gal
  • Extras: Ice compartment and remote control
  • Filter: Washable dust filter
  • Use: Bedrooms, offices and living rooms
  • Sold as: Single unit
  • Listing: Verified

Honeywell CL30XC: fits and best for

This cooler fits a homeowner cooling a bedroom, a home office or a living room in dry heat. It suits anyone who wants a quiet indoor cooler with a remote and an ice compartment, rather than a workshop unit.

Honeywell CL30XC pros and watch-outs

  • Made for indoor rooms
  • Ice compartment for colder air
  • Remote control included
  • Washable dust filter
  • Quiet enough for a bedroom
  • Smallest airflow in this guide
  • Needs dry air to work well
  • Ice compartment needs regular filling
  • Warranty not published in the listing

Honeywell CL30XC: what owners report

Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the CL30XC keeps a bedroom comfortable on hot nights, and the remote means no getting up to change the speed.

Owners also report the ice compartment gives a useful cold boost. HomeAir covers the Honeywell indoor cooler in its evaporative cooler reviews.

Honeywell CL30XC: who should not buy

Do not buy this for a garage or a patio, because 525 CFM is too little for an open space. The Hessaire coolers suit large and outdoor spaces better.

Honeywell CL30XC: pair it with

Pair it with a frozen water bottle in the ice compartment, so the air stays cold without buying bagged ice.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Keep a window cracked open: evaporative cooling needs fresh dry air coming in. Best Performance Monitors Under 100

Best Tower Fan: Lasko T42951 42 Inch Wind Curve Tower Fan with Remote

Best Tower Fan

Why the Lasko T42951 is our pick

The Lasko T42951 is the fan pick because it cools without water, which matters where evaporative cooling cannot work. It is a 42-inch Wind Curve tower fan with three quiet speeds, widespread oscillation and a remote control, so it moves air across a whole room from a slim footprint. A tower fan does not drop the air temperature the way an evaporative cooler does, but it makes a room feel cooler by moving air over skin, and it works in humid air where a swamp cooler fails. For a bedroom, an office or a humid room, this is the alternative to buy. It is the fan for a room where the air is too damp for evaporation to work.

Lasko T42951 key specs

  • Type: Oscillating tower fan
  • Height: 42 in
  • Speeds: 3 quiet speeds
  • Oscillation: Widespread
  • Remote: Included
  • Use: Bedrooms, offices and living rooms
  • Power: Low, fan only
  • Sold as: Single unit
  • Listing: Verified by fallback

Lasko T42951: fits and best for

This fan fits a homeowner in a humid climate, or anyone who wants moving air without water, tanks or humidity. It suits bedrooms and offices where a slim tower fan can stand in a corner and oscillate across the room.

Lasko T42951 pros and watch-outs

  • Works in humid air
  • Slim 42-inch footprint
  • Remote control included
  • Three quiet speeds
  • No water, no tank, no refilling
  • Does not lower air temperature
  • Less cooling than an evaporative cooler
  • Oscillation can be noisy on high
  • Warranty not published in the listing

Lasko T42951: what owners report

Owner reports in retailer reviews commonly note the T42951 moves a lot of air quietly, and the remote makes it easy to use from bed or a desk.

Owners also report it is a long-running model with a large owner base. ExpertBeacon lists the T42951 as a high-demand tower fan.

Lasko T42951: who should not buy

Do not buy this if you want the air temperature to drop, because a fan moves air without cooling it. An evaporative cooler suits dry heat better.

Lasko T42951: pair it with

Pair it with an open window at night, so the fan pulls in cool evening air.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Point the fan across the room, not at a wall: oscillation works best with a clear path. Best Storage Bins

Spec comparison

SpecHessaire MC37MHessaire MC18MHoneywell CL30XCLasko T42951
Airflow3,100 CFM1,300 CFM525 CFMTower fan
CoverageUp to 950 sq ftUp to 500 sq ftUp to 320 sq ftOne room
Water tank10.3 gal4.8 gal7.9 galNone
PowerFan and pumpFan and pumpFan and pumpFan only
NoiseNot published53.4 dBNot publishedQuiet, 3 speeds
RemoteNoNoYesYes
Best climateHot, dry airHot, dry airHot, dry airAny, including humid
Best forLarge spacesMid-size roomsBedrooms and officesHumid rooms
SpeedsNot published2-speedNot published3 speeds
WheelsYesYesNot statedNo
FilterNot statedNot statedWashable dust filterNone
Tank refillHose or bucketHose or bucketHose or bucketNone needed
Check PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price

How to use an evaporative cooler

Start by placing the cooler near an open window or door, with the airflow pointed into the room. Fill the tank, run the pump for a few minutes so the media soaks through, then switch the fan on. A cooler with dry media blows warm air, so wet media first is the rule. Best Tow Ropes Under 100

Keep a window or door open on the far side of the room, so the cooled air flows through instead of building up humidity. In a sealed room the cooler adds moisture until the air is saturated, and then it stops cooling. Fresh dry air coming in is what makes the system work. Battery Tender Junior vs NOCO Genius1

When you are done, run the fan without the pump for 30 minutes to dry the media before storing the cooler. A damp cooler grows musty, and a musty cooler blows musty air next time. Empty the tank, wipe it dry, and store the unit with the media dry. Warning Lights Reviews

Finally, check the water level before a long run, and keep a hose or a bucket nearby. A cooler that runs dry blows warm air and can damage the pump, so a quick look at the tank before you start saves a hot afternoon. Empty the tank at the end of the day if you will not use the cooler tomorrow. Best First Aid Kit Under 50

Safety essentials

  • Never run an evaporative cooler in a sealed room: it needs fresh air coming in.
  • Keep the cooler clear of electronics and outlets, because it holds water.
  • Unplug the cooler before filling the tank or cleaning the media.
  • Check the power cord for damage before each season, and replace it if it is frayed.
  • Do not use an evaporative cooler where the humidity is already high.
  • Keep the cooler on a flat, stable surface so it cannot tip and spill.

An evaporative cooler is a simple machine, but it holds water and moves air through your home. Fresh air in, dry media for storage, and a stable spot keep the job safe.

Anker 320 24W Dual-USB Mini Car Charger, to keep a phone charged while you work.

LISEN 48W USB C Car Charger Adapter 2 Pack, so a phone and a second device stay charged.

UGREEN 130W USB C Car Charger with Cable, for fast charging on long days away from home.

Troubleshooting

Most cooler faults trace to dry media, humid air or a dirty tank, and the fix is usually a check rather than a replacement. Warning Lights Reviews

SymptomLikely causeFix
Cooler blows warm airMedia dry, or pump not runningFill the tank, run the pump, and wait for the media to soak
Not cooling in humidityAir too humid for evaporationUse a fan or an air conditioner instead
Musty smellMedia stored dampDry the media fully, and clean or replace it
Water leaksTank overfilled or crackedFill to the line, and check the tank for cracks
Fan noisyDust on the blades, or a worn bearingClean the blades, and check the fan for wear
Remote will not workDead remote batteryFit a fresh battery and check the remote range
Cooler tips overOn uneven ground, or bumpedPlace it on flat ground, clear of foot traffic
Pump runs but no water flowsClogged pump or dry tankClean the pump filter and fill the tank

Who should NOT buy these

Do not buy an evaporative cooler for a humid climate. Evaporative cooling adds moisture to air that is already wet, so it cannot cool. A tower fan or a portable air conditioner suits humid rooms better. Best First Aid Kit Under 50

Do not buy a cooler that is too small for the space. A 525 CFM cooler cannot cool a garage, and it will run all day without catching up. Match the airflow to the room size, and step up to the MC37M for large spaces. ABS Scan Tools vs OBDII

Do not buy a cooler and run it in a sealed room. An evaporative cooler needs fresh dry air coming in and moist air going out, or the room saturates and the cooling stops. Keep a window or door open on the far side of the room. AGM Batteries Review for Cars

Do not buy a cooler and skip the drying step. A cooler stored damp grows musty, and the smell comes back with the next use. Run the fan for 30 minutes to dry the media before storing it. AGM Batteries Cost

Final verdict

Best Overall: Hessaire MC37M Check Price — the cooler to buy first for large spaces.

Best Mid-Size: Hessaire MC18M Check Price — the mid-size cooler to buy.

Best Indoor Room Cooler: Honeywell CL30XC Check Price — the indoor cooler to buy.

Best Tower Fan: Lasko T42951 Check Price — the fan to buy where water cooling cannot work.

FAQ

Do evaporative coolers really work?

Yes, in hot, dry air. An evaporative cooler draws hot air through water-soaked media, and the evaporating water drops the air temperature. It works best where the humidity is low, and it fails where the air is already humid, because wet air cannot take more moisture.

What is the best alternative to air conditioning?

In dry heat, an evaporative cooler is the best alternative, because it cools real air for a fraction of the power. In humid heat, a tower fan or a portable air conditioner is better, because a swamp cooler cannot work in wet air. Match the alternative to your climate first.

How much power does an evaporative cooler use?

Far less than an air conditioner, because it runs a fan and a small pump rather than a compressor. A tower fan uses less still. Check the wattage on the listing before you buy, and compare it with the air conditioner you are replacing.

Can I use an evaporative cooler indoors?

Yes, if the air is dry and a window or door stays open for fresh air. The Honeywell CL30XC is made for indoor rooms. In a sealed room the cooler adds humidity until the air saturates, and then it stops cooling, so ventilation matters.

Why is my swamp cooler blowing warm air?

The usual cause is dry media: the pump is not running, the tank is empty, or the media has not soaked through. Fill the tank, run the pump for a few minutes, and wait for the media to wet fully before judging the air temperature.

Do evaporative coolers add humidity?

Yes, that is how they work: evaporating water cools the air and adds moisture to it. In dry heat that is a benefit, and in humid heat it is a problem. If your room already feels damp, a swamp cooler is the wrong tool.

How often do I need to refill an evaporative cooler?

It depends on the tank size and the heat. A 10.3-gallon tank runs for hours in a large cooler, while a 4.8-gallon tank needs refilling sooner. Check the water level before a long run, and keep a hose or a bucket nearby for refills.

Is a tower fan better than an evaporative cooler?

It depends on the climate. A tower fan works in any humidity and needs no water, but it only moves air without dropping its temperature. An evaporative cooler drops the temperature in dry air, but it fails in humidity. Pick the fan for humid rooms, and the cooler for dry heat.

How do I clean an evaporative cooler?

Empty the tank, wipe it dry, and clean or replace the media when it smells musty or looks clogged. Run the fan for 30 minutes to dry the media before storing the cooler, and check the pump and the filter at the start of each season.

Can I use an evaporative cooler in a garage with the door closed?

No, not well. An evaporative cooler needs fresh dry air coming in and moist air going out, so a closed garage saturates quickly and the cooling stops. Crack the garage door or a window, and place the cooler near the opening so it draws in dry air. A fan alone is a better choice for a sealed space. Open a window on the far side of the room so the moist air has somewhere to go.

Sources

By Leo, Founder, WinchInsider

Leo researches winches and automotive accessories from maker documents, listing evidence and owner reports, and writes every guide so a first-time buyer can choose with confidence.

Related guides

Hessaire MC37M Evaporative Cooler, 3,100 CFM

Leave a Comment