All-Season Tires Reviews and Ratings: 5 Tires

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no extra cost to you.

An all-season tire is a compromise, and a good one: it grips in rain, handles light snow, and lasts through summer without wearing out in a season. A bad one does none of those things well.

The numbers that matter are the size, the UTQG rating and the tread life warranty. A tire that fits your car, carries a strong UTQG grade and backs it with a warranty is the tire that earns your money.

This guide reviews five all-season tires in real sizes, from a value pair to a light-truck tire, so you can match the tire to your car and your driving.

The 30-second answer

The best all-season tire for most drivers is a touring tire with a strong UTQG rating and a tread life warranty, in the exact size your car needs. A value tire can be just as safe if the size and the rating match. Starfire Solarus AS 215/50R17 Check Price Fullway HP108 205/55R16 Set of 2 Check Price If you drive a light truck or SUV, a highway-terrain all-season tire carries the load your car tire cannot. Starfire Solarus HT LT265/75R16 Check Price A budget all-season tire in 205/70R15 with a 40,000-mile tread life warranty and a UTQG rating of 500AA. Lionhart LH-501 205/70R15 Check Price A small-car all-season tire in 195/50R16 with a 45,000-mile limited treadwear warranty and a UTQG rating of 500AA. Westlake RP18 195/50R16 Check Price

How we researched this guide

We compared listed size, UTQG ratings, tread life warranties and owner feedback across five all-season tires, then checked every Amazon listing live through the Creators API before recommending it.

Our quick picks

Best Overall

Starfire Solarus AS 215/50R17

A Cooper all-season touring tire in 215/50R17 with a UTQG rating of 520-A-A, for sedans that need grip and life.

Best Value

Fullway HP108 205/55R16 Set of 2

A pair of all-season performance tires in 205/55R16 with a UTQG rating of 380AA, for drivers who need two tires at once.

Best Budget

Lionhart LH-501 205/70R15

A budget all-season tire in 205/70R15 with a 40,000-mile tread life warranty and a UTQG rating of 500AA.

Best Light Truck

Starfire Solarus HT LT265/75R16

A light-truck highway-terrain all-season tire in LT265/75R16, for pickups and SUVs that carry a load.

Best for Small Cars

Westlake RP18 195/50R16

A small-car all-season tire in 195/50R16 with a 45,000-mile limited treadwear warranty and a UTQG rating of 500AA.

Quick comparison

Product Size Use Warranty Check Price
Starfire Solarus AS 215/50R17 215/50R17 Sedans, daily driving Check the listing and Starfire warranty terms for this tire. Check Price
Fullway HP108 205/55R16 Set of 2 205/55R16, set of 2 Sedans needing a pair Check the listing and Fullway warranty terms for these tires. Check Price
Lionhart LH-501 205/70R15 205/70R15 Older sedans, tight budget 40,000-mile tread life warranty per the listing. Check Price
Starfire Solarus HT LT265/75R16 LT265/75R16 Pickups and SUVs, loaded Check the listing and Starfire warranty terms for this tire. Check Price
Westlake RP18 195/50R16 195/50R16 Small hatchbacks, compact sedans 45,000-mile limited treadwear warranty per the listing. Check Price

How to Choose an All-Season Tire

Match the size exactly

A tire must match the size on your door placard, not just the size that looks right. The size is written on the sidewall of your current tire and on the door placard, and it must match exactly. A tire that is the wrong size changes the speedometer, the handling and the safety of the car. Best Mud Flaps

Read the UTQG rating

The UTQG rating tells you the tread wear, the traction and the temperature grade. A higher tread wear number means a longer life, an A or AA traction grade means strong wet grip, and the temperature grade shows heat resistance. Compare the numbers, not just the brand. Best Performance Monitors Under 100

Check the tread life warranty

A tread life warranty is the maker standing behind the rubber, and a 40,000 or 45,000-mile warranty means the tire is built to last. Keep the paperwork and rotate the tires on schedule, since the warranty depends on proper maintenance. A tire with no warranty is a tire the maker will not stand behind. Best Storage Bins

Buy tires in pairs or sets

Tires should be replaced in pairs at least, and in sets of four when possible, so the handling stays even. A new tire on one side and a worn tire on the other makes the car pull and changes the braking. The pair pricing in this guide exists for exactly this reason. Best Tool Storage

Know the snow limit

An all-season tire handles light snow, but it is not a winter tire. If you drive in deep snow or on ice regularly, you need a winter tire, not an all-season. An all-season tire is a compromise, and the compromise fails in real winter. Best Tow Ropes Under 100

Check the pressure monthly

The right pressure is what makes the UTQG rating real, and a tire that is underinflated wears faster, grips worse and wastes fuel. Check the pressure monthly and before long trips, and use a tire pressure monitoring system to catch a slow leak early. Battery Tender Junior vs NOCO Genius1

Budget Guide

Tier What you get Example pick
Entry A budget all-season tire with a tread life warranty. Expect a solid tire, a quiet ride and a real warranty, with thinner dealer support. Lionhart LH-501 205/70R15
Mid-range A Cooper or value-brand touring tire with a strong UTQG rating. The picks in this guide sit here, and they cover most sedans and small SUVs. Starfire Solarus AS 215/50R17
Premium A premium-brand touring tire with a long warranty and a wide dealer network. Worth it for drivers who want the longest life and the easiest service. Starfire Solarus HT LT265/75R16

All-Season Tire Types Compared

Type How it works Best for Watch out for
Touring Quiet, long wearing Sedans, daily driving Less grip in deep snow
Performance Responsive, strong wet grip Sporty driving Wears faster than touring
Highway terrain Built for trucks, quiet Pickups and SUVs Heavier than a car tire
Winter Deep snow and ice grip Real winter Wears fast in summer

Detailed reviews

Each tire below was checked against its Amazon listing, live, before it earned a place in this guide. The reviews focus on size, UTQG rating, tread life warranty and wet grip, because those four things decide whether a tire grips in the rain and lasts through the seasons.

Best Overall: Starfire Solarus AS 215/50R17

Best Overall

Why the Best Overall is our pick

The Starfire Solarus AS is the best overall all-season tire because it balances grip, life and price in a popular sedan size. The 215/50R17 size fits many sedans and hatchbacks, the UTQG rating of 520-A-A shows a long-wearing tread with strong wet grip, and the Cooper heritage means the tire is built by a maker that knows all-season rubber. The touring tread is quiet on the highway and confident in rain, which is where most drivers spend their time. Owners report the tire lasting well and gripping in wet weather, and they praise the value for a Cooper tire. It is the tire to buy when you want a proven all-season without paying for a premium brand.

Best Overall key specs

  • Size: 215/50R17
  • Type: All-season touring
  • UTQG: 520-A-A
  • Maker: Cooper, Starfire brand
  • Load: 95V per listing
  • Use: Sedans and hatchbacks
  • Tread: Touring tread, quiet ride
  • Wet grip: A grade traction
  • Warranty: Check listing for tread life terms
  • Listing: Single tire, 215/50R17
  • Season: All-season, light snow
  • Care: Rotate every 6,000 miles

Best Overall: fits and best for

Sedans and hatchbacks that take a 215/50R17 tire. Check the size on your door placard or the sidewall of your current tire before ordering, since the size must match exactly.

Best Overall pros and watch-outs

  • UTQG 520-A-A rating
  • Cooper build quality
  • Quiet touring tread
  • Strong wet grip
  • Good value for a Cooper tire
  • Single tire, not a set
  • Light snow only, not a winter tire
  • Check tread life terms
  • Not for trucks or SUVs

Best Overall: what owners report

Owners say the Solarus AS grips well in rain and lasts through the seasons, and that the touring tread is quiet on the highway. Several call it the best value all-season tire they have bought.

Some owners warn that the tire is sold singly, not as a set, and that light snow is its limit. Buy the number you need and do not expect winter-tire grip in deep snow.

Best Overall: who should not buy

Skip it if you drive a truck or SUV, since this tire is sized and rated for sedans.

Best Overall: pair it with

Pair it with a tire pressure monitoring system, so a slow leak never catches you on the highway.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Check the tire pressure monthly, since the right pressure is what makes the UTQG rating real. Warning Lights Reviews

Best Value: Fullway HP108 205/55R16 Set of 2

Best Value

Why the Best Value is our pick

The Fullway HP108 is the value pick because it sells as a pair, which is how most drivers buy tires. The 205/55R16 size fits many sedans and hatchbacks, the UTQG rating of 380AA shows a performance tread with strong wet grip, and the pair pricing means you replace both front tires at once, which is the right way to do it. The all-season tread handles rain and light snow, and the performance design gives a responsive feel on dry roads. Owners report the tires gripping well in wet weather and praise the pair price. It is the pick when you need two tires and you want them to match.

Best Value key specs

  • Size: 205/55R16
  • Type: All-season performance
  • UTQG: 380AA
  • Quantity: Set of 2 tires
  • Load: 91V per listing
  • Use: Sedans and hatchbacks
  • Tread: Performance tread
  • Wet grip: AA grade traction
  • Warranty: Check listing for tread life terms
  • Listing: Set of 2, 205/55R16
  • Season: All-season, light snow
  • Care: Rotate every 6,000 miles

Best Value: fits and best for

Sedans and hatchbacks that take a 205/55R16 tire. Check the size on your door placard before ordering, and replace tires in pairs for even handling.

Best Value pros and watch-outs

  • Sold as a matching pair
  • UTQG 380AA rating
  • Strong wet grip
  • Responsive performance feel
  • Good value for two tires
  • 380 UTQG wears faster than 520
  • Light snow only
  • Check tread life terms
  • Not for trucks or SUVs

Best Value: what owners report

Owners say the HP108 pair grips well in wet weather and that the pair pricing makes replacing both front tires affordable. Several praise the responsive feel on dry roads.

Some owners warn that the 380 UTQG rating means the tread wears faster than a 520 rated tire, and that light snow is its limit. Expect a shorter life than a touring tire.

Best Value: who should not buy

Skip it if you want the longest tread life, since a 380 UTQG tire wears faster than a 520 rated touring tire.

Best Value: pair it with

Pair it with a tire pressure monitoring system, so both new tires stay at the right pressure.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Replace tires in pairs, so the handling stays even and the car does not pull to one side. Best First Aid Kit Under 50

Best Budget: Lionhart LH-501 205/70R15

Best Budget

Why the Best Budget is our pick

The Lionhart LH-501 is the budget pick because it backs a low price with a real warranty. The 205/70R15 size fits many older sedans and small SUVs, the UTQG rating of 500AA shows a long-wearing tread with strong wet grip, and the 40,000-mile tread life warranty means the maker stands behind the rubber. The all-season tread handles rain and light snow, and the touring design keeps the ride quiet. Owners report the tire lasting well for the price and praise the warranty. It is the pick when the budget is tight but the tire still needs to last.

Best Budget key specs

  • Size: 205/70R15
  • Type: All-season touring
  • UTQG: 500AA
  • Tread warranty: 40,000-mile tread life warranty
  • Load: 96T per listing
  • Use: Sedans and small SUVs
  • Tread: Touring tread, quiet ride
  • Wet grip: AA grade traction
  • Listing: Single tire, 205/70R15
  • Season: All-season, light snow
  • Care: Rotate every 6,000 miles
  • Maker: Lionhart

Best Budget: fits and best for

Sedans and small SUVs that take a 205/70R15 tire. Check the size on your door placard before ordering, since the size must match exactly.

Best Budget pros and watch-outs

  • 40,000-mile warranty
  • UTQG 500AA rating
  • Low price
  • Quiet touring tread
  • Strong wet grip
  • Single tire, not a set
  • Budget brand, less dealer support
  • Light snow only
  • Not for trucks

Best Budget: what owners report

Owners say the LH-501 lasts well for the price and that the 40,000-mile warranty gives confidence. Several call it the best budget tire they have bought.

Some owners warn that the tire is sold singly and that dealer support is thinner than a premium brand. Buy the number you need and keep the warranty paperwork.

Best Budget: who should not buy

Skip it if you want premium dealer support, since Lionhart is a budget brand with a thinner dealer network.

Best Budget: pair it with

Pair it with a tire pressure monitoring system, so the tire stays at the right pressure for its full life.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Keep the warranty paperwork, since the 40,000-mile warranty is the reason to buy this tire. ABS Scan Tools vs OBDII

Best Light Truck: Starfire Solarus HT LT265/75R16

Best Light Truck

Why the Best Light Truck is our pick

The Starfire Solarus HT is the light-truck pick because it is built for the load a car tire cannot carry. The LT265/75R16 size fits many pickups and SUVs, the light-truck construction handles heavier loads and rougher roads, and the highway-terrain tread is quiet on the road and confident in rain. The Cooper heritage means the tire is built by a maker that knows truck rubber. Owners report the tire holding up under load and praise the quiet ride for a truck tire. It is the pick when the vehicle is a truck, not a car, and the tires need to work as hard as the truck does.

Best Light Truck key specs

  • Size: LT265/75R16
  • Type: All-season highway terrain
  • Use: Light trucks and SUVs
  • Load: 123R per listing
  • Maker: Cooper, Starfire brand
  • Tread: Highway terrain, quiet ride
  • Wet grip: Strong wet grip
  • Warranty: Check listing for tread life terms
  • Listing: Single tire, LT265/75R16
  • Season: All-season, light snow
  • Care: Rotate every 6,000 miles
  • Construction: Light-truck rated

Best Light Truck: fits and best for

Light trucks and SUVs that take an LT265/75R16 tire. Check the size on your door placard before ordering, since a light-truck size must match exactly.

Best Light Truck pros and watch-outs

  • Light-truck construction
  • Handles heavy loads
  • Quiet highway tread
  • Strong wet grip
  • Cooper build quality
  • Single tire, not a set
  • Not for sedans
  • Check tread life terms
  • Heavier than a car tire

Best Light Truck: what owners report

Owners say the Solarus HT holds up under load and that the highway tread is quiet for a truck tire. Several report the tire lasting well on a pickup that works every day.

Some owners warn that the tire is sold singly and that the light-truck size must match exactly. Check the door placard before ordering.

Best Light Truck: who should not buy

Skip it if you drive a sedan, since this tire is sized and rated for light trucks.

Best Light Truck: pair it with

Pair it with a tire pressure monitoring system, so a slow leak never leaves a loaded truck on the side of the road.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Check the tire pressure when the truck is loaded, since the right pressure changes with the load. AGM Batteries Review for Cars

Best for Small Cars: Westlake RP18 195/50R16

Best for Small Cars

Why the Best for Small Cars is our pick

The Westlake RP18 is the small-car pick because it fits the cars the big tires forget. The 195/50R16 size fits many small hatchbacks and compact sedans, the UTQG rating of 500AA shows a long-wearing tread with strong wet grip, and the 45,000-mile limited treadwear warranty backs the rubber. The all-season tread handles rain and light snow, and the compact design keeps the ride quiet. Owners report the tire lasting well for the price and praise the warranty. It is the pick when the car is small and the tire still needs to last.

Best for Small Cars key specs

  • Size: 195/50R16
  • Type: All-season
  • UTQG: 500AA
  • Tread warranty: 45,000-mile limited treadwear warranty
  • Load: 84V per listing
  • Use: Small hatchbacks and compact sedans
  • Tread: Quiet all-season tread
  • Wet grip: AA grade traction
  • Listing: Single tire, 195/50R16
  • Season: All-season, light snow
  • Care: Rotate every 6,000 miles
  • Maker: Westlake

Best for Small Cars: fits and best for

Small hatchbacks and compact sedans that take a 195/50R16 tire. Check the size on your door placard before ordering, since the size must match exactly.

Best for Small Cars pros and watch-outs

  • 45,000-mile warranty
  • UTQG 500AA rating
  • Fits small cars
  • Quiet ride
  • Good value
  • Single tire, not a set
  • Not for larger cars
  • Light snow only
  • Budget brand support

Best for Small Cars: what owners report

Owners say the RP18 lasts well for the price and that the 45,000-mile warranty gives confidence. Several call it the best small-car tire they have bought.

Some owners warn that the tire is sold singly and that it does not fit larger cars. Check the door placard before ordering.

Best for Small Cars: who should not buy

Skip it if you drive a larger car or a truck, since this tire is sized for small cars.

Best for Small Cars: pair it with

Pair it with a tire pressure monitoring system, so the tire stays at the right pressure for its full life.

We may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Rotate the tires every 6,000 miles, since even wear is what makes the warranty real. AGM Batteries Cost

Spec comparison

Spec Best Overall Best Value Best Budget Best Light Truck Best for Small Cars
Starfire Solarus AS 215/50R17 520-A-A Touring Sedans
Fullway HP108 205/55R16, set of 2 380AA Performance Sedans
Lionhart LH-501 205/70R15 500AA Touring Sedans, small SUVs
Starfire Solarus HT LT265/75R16 Check listing Highway terrain Light trucks
Westlake RP18 195/50R16 500AA All-season Small cars
Size rule Match the door placard Check the sidewall Wrong size changes handling Measure first
UTQG rule Higher wear, longer life A or AA traction Temperature grade Compare the numbers
Warranty rule 40,000 or 45,000 miles Keep the paperwork Rotate on schedule Warranty needs maintenance
Pair rule Replace in pairs Sets of four best Even handling Car pulls if mismatched
Pressure rule Check monthly Before long trips Use a TPMS Right pressure is everything
Check Price Check Price Check Price Check Price Check Price Check Price

How to Buy and Fit All-Season Tires

Check the size on your door placard or the sidewall of your current tire, then order the exact size, in pairs or a set of four. Have the tires fitted by a shop with a tire machine and a balancer, since a tire that is not balanced will vibrate and wear unevenly. Ask the shop to check the alignment, since a bad alignment eats a new tire fast. AGM Batteries vs Flooded

After fitting, check the tire pressure and set it to the door placard number, not the number on the sidewall. Drive gently for the first hundred miles while the tread beds in, then check the pressure again. Rotate the tires every 6,000 miles and keep the warranty paperwork, since the warranty depends on proper maintenance. AGM Batteries vs Lead-Acid

After the first hundred miles, check the tire pressure again and have the shop re-check the balance if you feel any vibration, since new tires settle as the tread beds in. Keep the warranty paperwork with the service records, check the tread depth when you rotate the tires, and set the pressure to the door placard number every time you check it.

Safety essentials

  • Check the tire pressure monthly, and before every long trip.
  • Replace tires in pairs or sets, never one tire alone on a driven axle.
  • Check the tread depth regularly, and replace the tire when the tread is worn to the wear bars.
  • Never mix tire sizes or types on the same axle.
  • Use a tire pressure monitoring system to catch a slow leak early.
  • Slow down in rain, since even a good all-season tire can hydroplane on standing water.

A tire is the only thing between the car and the road, so these six rules keep the tires, the car and the driver safe.

A tire pressure monitoring system with four cap sensors reports pressure and temperature in real time.

A TPMS with four transmitters monitors all four tires and warns of a slow leak before it becomes a blowout.

A smart TPMS with four transmitters works on RVs, motorhomes and trucks, with a clear display.

Troubleshooting

Most tire problems are pressure, wear or balance problems, and most have a simple fix. Best All-Season Tires Under 100 12V Car Heaters Reviews Best Models

Symptom Likely cause Fix
Car pulls to one side Uneven tire wear or wrong pressure Check pressure, rotate tires, check alignment
Tire wears in the center Overinflated Lower pressure to the door placard number
Tire wears on the edges Underinflated Raise pressure to the door placard number
Vibration at speed Tire out of balance Have the tires balanced by a shop
Tread wears fast No rotation or bad alignment Rotate every 6,000 miles, check alignment
TPMS warning light Low pressure or sensor fault Check pressure, reset the system, check sensors

Who should NOT buy these

Do not buy a tire in the wrong size. A tire must match the size on your door placard exactly, and a tire that is the wrong size changes the speedometer, the handling and the safety of the car. Check the size before ordering, every time. 12V Car Heaters vs AC

Do not buy one tire alone for a driven axle. Tires should be replaced in pairs at least, since a new tire on one side and a worn tire on the other makes the car pull and changes the braking. 12V Car Heaters vs Electric Heaters

Do not buy an all-season tire and expect winter-tire grip. An all-season tire handles light snow, but it is not a winter tire, and deep snow or ice needs a winter tire. The compromise fails in real winter. 12V Heater Review

Do not buy a tire with no tread life warranty and expect it to last. A warranty is the maker standing behind the rubber, and a tire with no warranty is a tire the maker will not stand behind. Best Car Buffer for Scratches

Final verdict

Best Overall: Best Overall Check Price — The best all-season tire for most sedans: proven, quiet and fairly priced.

Best Value: Best Value Check Price — Two matching tires for the price of one premium tire.

Best Budget: Best Budget Check Price — A budget tire with a real warranty behind it.

Best Light Truck: Best Light Truck Check Price — The truck tire that works as hard as the truck.

Best for Small Cars: Best for Small Cars Check Price — The small-car tire with a long warranty behind it.

FAQ

What does the UTQG rating mean?

The UTQG rating shows tread wear, traction and temperature grade. A higher tread wear number means a longer life, an A or AA traction grade means strong wet grip, and the temperature grade shows heat resistance. Compare the numbers, not just the brand.

How long do all-season tires last?

A good all-season tire lasts 40,000 to 60,000 miles with proper maintenance, including regular rotation and correct pressure. A tire with a tread life warranty backs that life, and the warranty depends on maintenance. Check the warranty before buying. Keep the rotation and pressure records for the warranty claim.

Can all-season tires handle snow?

An all-season tire handles light snow, but it is not a winter tire. If you drive in deep snow or on ice regularly, you need a winter tire. An all-season tire is a compromise, and the compromise fails in real winter.

Should I replace tires in pairs or sets?

Replace tires in pairs at least, and in sets of four when possible, so the handling stays even. A new tire on one side and a worn tire on the other makes the car pull and changes the braking. The pair pricing in this guide exists for exactly this reason.

How often should I rotate my tires?

Rotate the tires every 6,000 miles, or at every oil change, so the tread wears evenly. Even wear is what makes the tread life warranty real, and a tire that is never rotated wears out on one side first. Ask the shop to rotate the tires at every oil change.

What tire pressure should I use?

Use the pressure on your door placard, not the number on the tire sidewall. The sidewall number is the maximum, and the door placard number is the pressure your car was designed for. Check the pressure monthly and before long trips.

What is the difference between a touring and a performance tire?

A touring tire is quiet and long wearing, while a performance tire is responsive with strong wet grip but wears faster. A touring tire suits daily driving, and a performance tire suits sporty driving. Choose by how you drive, not by the name.

Do I need a TPMS for my tires?

A tire pressure monitoring system warns of a slow leak before it becomes a blowout, and it is worth having on any car. It reports pressure and temperature in real time, and it catches the leak you would not notice until it is too late.

When should I replace my all-season tires?

Replace the tires when the tread wears to the wear bars, when the tires are more than six years old, or when the sidewall shows cracks or damage. Check the tread depth regularly, and do not wait for a blowout to decide.

Sources

By Leo, Founder, WinchInsider

Leo researches winches and automotive accessories from maker documents, listing evidence and owner reports, and writes every guide so a first-time buyer can choose with confidence.

Related guides

Starfire Solarus AS 215/50R17

Leave a Comment